EXV: 2013 Rookie Draft

[Adamant]

Holz has the better team this year (but could still go either way), but the Bashers will be unstoppable when Fyfe, Swallow, Murphy improve and when Holz' older players like Boyd, Harvey and Petrie retire.

[Ziplock]

including captain bonus, I have the bashers sitting on an average of 1501 from their best 15, while I have the eagles on 1581.


A summary of positional averages (rounded down for everything)

Defenders:
Eagles: 95
Bashers: 81

Mids:
Eagles: 113
Bashers: 102

Rucks:
Eagles: 100
Bashers: 90
Forwards:
Eagles: 85
Bashers: 95

Utilities:
Eagles: 95
Bashers: 95

[Justin Bieber]

Holz has like Walker as Forward cover. O'Meara as mid cover and no one has back cover. So he is introuble haha.

[Ziplock]

doesnt he have c. pearce as mid cover as well?

and malceski/ thompson aren't terrible cover...

[Justin Bieber]

doesnt he have c. pearce as mid cover as well?

and malceski/ thompson aren't terrible cover...

Oh yeah forgot...  :-X  Better than I thought...

[Holz]

doesnt he have c. pearce as mid cover as well?

and malceski/ thompson aren't terrible cover...

Oh yeah forgot...  :-X  Better than I thought...

harpr for his 3rd year breakout and schineder up front. But yeah im going to be in trouble down back in a few years. Going to have to rely on pearce swallow hogan harper and omeara coming good to replace my guns.

[Ricochet]

including captain bonus, I have the bashers sitting on an average of 1501 from their best 15, while I have the eagles on 1581.


A summary of positional averages (rounded down for everything)

Defenders:
Eagles: 95
Bashers: 81

Mids:
Eagles: 113
Bashers: 102

Rucks:
Eagles: 100
Bashers: 90
Forwards:
Eagles: 85
Bashers: 95

Utilities:
Eagles: 95
Bashers: 95

That's a pretty fair analysis I reckon
I don't think we will have anyone in our starting mids/utilities go under 100 tho
And naturally we're expecting a little more out of our backline but Holz is a fair bit ahead there

[Ziplock]

I have priddis at 93 :P

your 4th defender drags you guys down :P

[JBs-Hawks]

Analyse all you like the Lions are gonna be thereabouts all year then overperform come finals and take the lot.

[Ricochet]

I have priddis at 93 :P

your 4th defender drags you guys down :P

Haha he did that this year and it was sub affected
Take that vest out and your looking at 99ish

Nicho or Pearce should go 75-80 as D4 but still nothing compared to a backline with Gibbs and Goddard

[Adamant]

You guys have a killer forward line though.

[Justin Bieber]

Analyse all you like the Lions are gonna be thereabouts all year then overperform come finals and take the lot.

Watch out we have a comedian ;D

[Ziplock]

I have priddis at 93 :P

your 4th defender drags you guys down :P

Haha he did that this year and it was sub affected
Take that vest out and your looking at 99ish

Nicho or Pearce should go 75-80 as D4 but still nothing compared to a backline with Gibbs and Goddard

he averaged 97 unsubbed :P

and I reaaaally dont see pearce going over 80.

[The F.A.R.K.]

Both teams with the better player in bold:

Eagles: B.Gibbs, B.Goddard, H.Shaw, J.Adcock
Bashers: G.Birchall, D.Stanley, B.Houli, D.Pearce

Eagles: S.Pendlebury, M.Boyd, B.Deledio, M.Barlow
Bashers: M.Murphy, A.Swallow, N.Fyfe, M.Priddis

Eagles: T.Goldstein
Bashers: H.McIntosh

Eagles: T.Cloke, M.LeCras, B.Harvey, D.Petrie
Bashers: D.Thomas, M.Robinson, M.Pavlich, C.Rioli

Eagles: A.Carrazzo, S.Grigg
Bashers: D.Swallow, A.Sandilands



Eagles have the better team.

Fyfe and lids are even imo
Priddis ave 97 without sub game so he beats barlow
Holz defence beats us just marginally while our fwds beat his how do i say it not by a lot but more than his def beats ours

Lets say holz def is 10-20ppg better than ours remembering stanley ave 92

Our fwds are 20-30ppg better than his

Our mids are fairly even. He may win by 5-10ppg depending if boyd holds a 115 average

Then our utilities win by 15 or so ppg carrots = sandi grigg > swallow

So our team is 15-30 ppg better overall

He might have 'more' better players but our overall team wins

Why not add last years averages all together then see who wins?

[Justin Bieber]

What^