EDIT: Best 22 for all clubs post draft, now finished!

Started by underdog11, November 26, 2012, 06:36:12 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Barra17

I'm not a Richmond supporter, but I would have thought Ellis would have been ahead of Morris from what I saw.

underdog11

Quote from: Barra on November 29, 2012, 01:29:47 PM
I'm not a Richmond supporter, but I would have thought Ellis would have been ahead of Morris from what I saw.

no way!

meow meow

Quote from: underdog11 on November 26, 2012, 06:36:12 PM

Western Bulldogs best team:

FB: D.Morris B.Lake E.Wood

HB: R.Murphy M.Talia L.Picken

C:T.Liberatore D.Cross M.Wallis

HF: A.Cooney J.Stringer J.Macrae

FF: D.Giansurcusia T.Dickson L.Dahlaus

R: W.Minson M.Boyd R.Griffin

I/C: C.Howard K.Stevens S.Higgins N.Hrovat (sub)

Emg: L.Markovic J.Grant J.Roughead


I don't think so.

Mr.Craig

Quote from: underdog11 on November 29, 2012, 01:49:03 PM
Quote from: Barra on November 29, 2012, 01:29:47 PM
I'm not a Richmond supporter, but I would have thought Ellis would have been ahead of Morris from what I saw.

no way!

Morris would be ahead, but that could change very quickly given Ellis' raw talent. Not that it really matters, Richmond have shown they're happy to play both of them in the same team.

underdog11

Quote from: meow meow on November 29, 2012, 04:09:52 PM
Quote from: underdog11 on November 26, 2012, 06:36:12 PM

Western Bulldogs best team:

FB: D.Morris B.Lake E.Wood

HB: R.Murphy M.Talia L.Picken

C:T.Liberatore D.Cross M.Wallis

HF: A.Cooney J.Stringer J.Macrae

FF: D.Giansurcusia T.Dickson L.Dahlaus

R: W.Minson M.Boyd R.Griffin

I/C: C.Howard K.Stevens S.Higgins N.Hrovat (sub)

Emg: L.Markovic J.Grant J.Roughead


I don't think so.

oops, thats embarrasing. Willams*

Toga

Quote from: underdog11 on November 29, 2012, 01:49:03 PM
Quote from: Barra on November 29, 2012, 01:29:47 PM
I'm not a Richmond supporter, but I would have thought Ellis would have been ahead of Morris from what I saw.

no way!

+1 no way, Morris is a jet.. Although so is Ellis, and I think there is certainly a spot for him in our team next year.

This is what I would have it looking like:


ichmond best team:

FB: D.Grimes  A.Rance  S.Morris

HB: C.Newman T.Chaplin B.Houli

C:   B.Deledio    D.Martin  S.Grigg

HF: C.Knights   T. Vickery   R. Nahas

FF: A.Edwards   J.Riewoldt  S.Edwards

R: I.Maric T.Cotchin, S.Tuck

I/C: R.Conca N.Foley, B.Ellis, N.Vlastuin (sub)

Emg: J.King, D.Jackson, M.White, J. Batchelor, T. Derickx

The_Captain

Quote from: popedelio on November 28, 2012, 04:01:32 AM
This is my guess for WCE

B: Darren Glass   Eric Mackenzie         Beau Waters
HB: Adam Selwood   Will Schofield         Shannon Hurn
C: Matthew Rosa   Scott Selwood         Andrew Gaff
HF: Luke Shuey   Jack Darling         Chris Masten
F: Dean Cox           Josh Kennedy         Mark LeCras
R: Nic Naitanui           Daniel Kerr         Matthew Priddis
I/C: Sharrod Wellingham       Josh Hill   Andrew Embley    sub: Patrick McGinnity
EMG: (Sam Butler   Mark Nicoski   Brad Sheppard)

to justify my choices
DEF: obviously KD Mitch Brown misses out, and rebounder Sam Butler doesn't make the 22 because A.Selwood is shutdown defender, though either players could swap
CTR: I couldnt really find any room for Wellingham to start on the wing or on the flank, which is why he is on the interchange. Same goes with Embley.
FWD: I believe Darling will player higher then Kennedy, though doesn't make a difference, they will both play along the spine. Cox and Nat will swap through forward line. I would have Shuey in the RUCK but Kerr and Priddis take those positions because they are veterans. Shuey and Masten will obviously rotate through midfield along with LeCras.
I/C: Josh Hill played a solid season in 2012, which is why he starts over Nicoski, though both could swap. McGinnity is sub only purely because he is a utility, tough and a pest, also love child of Worsfold 

Eagles have super depth in the midfield and small forwards, not sure how many games Morton, Hams, Sheppard and Dick etc can get if the list is healthy.

Very Very close to what i would have! WIth a full team i dont think Mcginnity is up to it. Butler and nicoski both before him. He was just lucky there were a lot of injuries last year.