Hey, how do i join in?

Started by kilbluff1985, November 25, 2012, 05:47:27 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

The_Captain

Quote from: Ringo on February 04, 2013, 08:46:20 PM
Not against a new team but I can forsee similar problems to what we currently have coaches having multiple teams again freezing out new coaches. If it goes ahead would like to see it restricted to caoches without a current team in any of the other 4 comps.

As an aside please feel free to comment here I am thinking of doing this with the British
Changing the names to British xv's Premier league.
Introducing a second League called British xv's 1st Division.  This league will be open to coaches and if enough interest will organise a draft when we say reach 8 coaches but can have up to 18 as well.
Will work out a promotion and relegation system between the 2,

Yeh thats the only fair way to give the people who don't already have a team a fair go! Dont know how you could do that when players would be doubled up when someone goes up or down leagues. Wouldn;t work unless the teams were reset every year!

JBs-Hawks

Quote from: Ringo on February 04, 2013, 08:46:20 PM
Not against a new team but I can forsee similar problems to what we currently have coaches having multiple teams again freezing out new coaches. If it goes ahead would like to see it restricted to caoches without a current team in any of the other 4 comps.

As an aside please feel free to comment here I am thinking of doing this with the British
Changing the names to British xv's Premier league.
Introducing a second League called British xv's 1st Division.  This league will be open to coaches and if enough interest will organise a draft when we say reach 8 coaches but can have up to 18 as well.
Will work out a promotion and relegation system between the 2,

Not sure how promotion would work? Maybe if the new comp didnt start until you had say 32 teams and every player is available twice. Then you could have two divisions with promoting and demoting and its a bit different to the other XVs.

The_Captain

Quote from: JBs-Hawks on February 04, 2013, 08:55:37 PM
Quote from: Ringo on February 04, 2013, 08:46:20 PM
Not against a new team but I can forsee similar problems to what we currently have coaches having multiple teams again freezing out new coaches. If it goes ahead would like to see it restricted to caoches without a current team in any of the other 4 comps.

As an aside please feel free to comment here I am thinking of doing this with the British
Changing the names to British xv's Premier league.
Introducing a second League called British xv's 1st Division.  This league will be open to coaches and if enough interest will organise a draft when we say reach 8 coaches but can have up to 18 as well.
Will work out a promotion and relegation system between the 2,

Not sure how promotion would work? Maybe if the new comp didnt start until you had say 32 teams and every player is available twice. Then you could have two divisions with promoting and demoting and its a bit different to the other XVs.

Better and eassier just to have new comp all together i reckon :)

BB67th

Quote from: Ringo on February 04, 2013, 08:46:20 PM
Not against a new team but I can forsee similar problems to what we currently have coaches having multiple teams again freezing out new coaches. If it goes ahead would like to see it restricted to caoches without a current team in any of the other 4 comps.

As an aside please feel free to comment here I am thinking of doing this with the British
Changing the names to British xv's Premier league.
Introducing a second League called British xv's 1st Division.  This league will be open to coaches and if enough interest will organise a draft when we say reach 8 coaches but can have up to 18 as well.
Will work out a promotion and relegation system between the 2,
Hmmmm its an interesting idea, but I don't think it would work. Players would all need to be drafted again, and when teams move up or down a league, you will start to get double ups of players, and not having them the same is one of the main parts of the XVs competitions.

The_Captain

Quote from: BB67th on February 04, 2013, 09:03:05 PM
Quote from: Ringo on February 04, 2013, 08:46:20 PM
Not against a new team but I can forsee similar problems to what we currently have coaches having multiple teams again freezing out new coaches. If it goes ahead would like to see it restricted to caoches without a current team in any of the other 4 comps.

As an aside please feel free to comment here I am thinking of doing this with the British
Changing the names to British xv's Premier league.
Introducing a second League called British xv's 1st Division.  This league will be open to coaches and if enough interest will organise a draft when we say reach 8 coaches but can have up to 18 as well.
Will work out a promotion and relegation system between the 2,
Hmmmm its an interesting idea, but I don't think it would work. Players would all need to be drafted again, and when teams move up or down a league, you will start to get double ups of players, and not having them the same is one of the main parts of the XVs competitions.

THis has already been said by 2 people in the above comments mate

kilbluff1985

i think people should only be head coach of 2 teams personally

i think if a reserves type thing is going to be made should be in WXV or EXV the 2 more popular comps

but yeah a new comp is just easier who cares what scoring it uses if enough coaches are interested why not some people are being a bit hmm cant think of the word about not having dupe scoring systems

elephants

I like this ^^

Belgian Bashers reserves coach - The Fark.

He loves the developing boys!

Justin Bieber

Nah flower ya. I can have as many teams as I want :P

Ringo

Thanks for the comments guys. Very stimulating discussion and something to consider all round. Will have to reconsider 1st division and how to keep teams unique on promotion if it goes ahead as an example of points raised in discussion.

Not sure of the best way forward and not to stifle everyone’s enthusiasm will keep exploring possibilities.   

Realise it is hard to give up teams so you would only have one team as coaches have spent time drafting and trading and want to keep team going forward. Especially in British and Asians as these are new competitions for this year.

Will follow this thread with interest.


Nails

Quote from: elephants on February 04, 2013, 09:23:01 PM
I like this ^^

Belgian Bashers reserves coach - The Fark.

He loves the developing boys!

tbagrocks

Quote from: whatlez on February 04, 2013, 10:46:09 PM
Nah flower ya. I can have as many teams as I want :P
And assistants ::)

Maca24

The new people just don't get it  ::)
Do you propose making a new comp everytime 3 people want to be involved?
Just be patient and wait for gaps.
Either that or I propose each person is aloud a maximum of 2 teams. Maybe even 1.

And if someone takes the Suns name ill be furious. Haha.

nrich102

Quote from: NigeyS on February 04, 2013, 07:51:38 PM
Texas Mules - JROO8
New York Apples - NigeyS
Florida Flow Riders
Nevada Aces - Toga
Maine Courses
California Suns - FisherSaints
Kansas Cairn Terriers
Alabama Slammers - kilbluff1985
Hawaii Surf
Kentucky Fried Chicken â€" SilkySkills
New Jersey Shores - Nails
Washington Presidents
Idaho Hoes - JBsHawks
Minnesota Sodas - Jayman
Pennsylvania Vampires - Hellopplz
Delaware Houses
Virginia Virgins
Alaska Malamutes

That was the original list I proposed as a joke and tentavily for the 'American XVs' for anybody that gives a flower.  :P
I'll take Alaska if this goes ahead Nigey, but I'll probably change the name :P


I like the idea of having a reserves comp or something like that and I like the idea of 1 or 2 teams maximum per person.

Nige

Quote from: nrich102 on February 05, 2013, 06:44:26 PM
Quote from: NigeyS on February 04, 2013, 07:51:38 PM
Texas Mules - JROO8
New York Apples - NigeyS
Florida Flow Riders
Nevada Aces - Toga
Maine Courses
California Suns - FisherSaints
Kansas Cairn Terriers
Alabama Slammers - kilbluff1985
Hawaii Surf
Kentucky Fried Chicken â€" SilkySkills
New Jersey Shores - Nails
Washington Presidents
Idaho Hoes - JBsHawks
Minnesota Sodas - Jayman
Pennsylvania Vampires - Hellopplz
Delaware Houses
Virginia Virgins
Alaska Malamutes

That was the original list I proposed as a joke and tentavily for the 'American XVs' for anybody that gives a flower.  :P
I'll take Alaska if this goes ahead Nigey, but I'll probably change the name :P


I like the idea of having a reserves comp or something like that and I like the idea of 1 or 2 teams maximum per person.

Just outta interest, what would you change it to?  :o

GM

Alaska Malamutes for me Nige.
Ours past away last month,15 years.
The Resurrection.