Sam Colquhoun

[Ziplock]

haha, all I was saying that if you were removing the record for 2012 because the crows cheated as pb saod, then logically you should removed 2010 and 11 records as well :P

[Grazz]

haha, all I was saying that if you were removing the record for 2012 because the crows cheated as pb saod, then logically you should removed 2010 and 11 records as well :P

Yeh i know, i was just saying how much i cared :P.  I guess if your club cheats then this is the stuff we as supporters have to wear, time to grow a few more skin layers i think and suck it up lol. :(

[Sapientia]

Just gonna throw it out there: Essendon and Collingwood aren't automatically the best AFL teams due to their premiership records. I'm sure recent success is weighted more heavily in assessing 'what one would want'

If I had a choice of an excellent past but awful now, or awful past but good now, I'd choose the latter. That's what I'm saying.

So yeah, 17-16; well done. It matters about as much as Essendon having a few flags over Richmond. I'm much more content with our recent record as that's what 'matters' to me.

Just like the inevitable days where Port will have a better list than us and you'll have the wood over us in the showdowns, irrelevant of the record overall if you're winning over a small period I'll give you guys the credit.

Sapientia.

[Ziplock]

your recent record doesn't count sapientia, you guys were cheating...l and port still won a majority of the games from the last few years :P

[Grazz]

your recent record doesn't count sapientia, you guys were cheating...l and port still won a majority of the games from the last few years :P

Not from the last few years zip. weve been busy playing catch up.

From 2010 its 3 all, Port won none last year.

From 2005 Crows 11, Port 6

Prior to that Port were well on top

[Sapientia]

While I'm not justifying our actions at all; I think our penalty was too lenient, but...

What we're guilty of isn't performance impacting. We broke a rule, teams do that often. I really don't think the clauses that were wrong impacted our performance.

Oh well though, I don't intend to start a flame war!

[Grazz]

While I'm not justifying our actions at all; I think our penalty was too lenient, but...

What we're guilty of isn't performance impacting. We broke a rule, teams do that often. I really don't think the clauses that were wrong impacted our performance.

Oh well though, I don't intend to start a flame war!

Had this out with Zip before, his argument will be we wouldnt of had Tippett as long as we did.

Cant argue we broke the rules/cheated but compared to what others have done its small time
but cheating is cheating and i except that.

We shoould stop hijacking this thread and head over to the Tippett thread really but im over it tbh.
The Crows V Port showdown topic is more interesting to me now.

[tbagrocks]

your recent record doesn't count sapientia, you guys were cheating...l and port still won a majority of the games from the last few years :P

Man GWS must have really cheated badly hey, I can't find any of their records prior to 2012 ???

[Ziplock]

?

the 'I' bit?

clearly a mistype at 1.30am ....

[tbagrocks]

His name is

Sam "K-hoon" Khoon, Sammy Colquhoun is pronounced Kahoon, from his dad! It is an old Scottish pronounciation

[Noz]

His name is

Sam "K-hoon" Khoon, Sammy Colquhoun is pronounced Kahoon, from his dad! It is an old Scottish pronounciation

I always thought it was pronounced Kol-Hoon.

[Tominator]

how many people are actually getting on him ?

Not sure on his JS but looks like a ball magnet... its a toss up between him, Vlastuin and Stevenson for my last two backline spots

[Toga]

how many people are actually getting on him ?

Not sure on his JS but looks like a ball magnet... its a toss up between him, Vlastuin and Stevenson for my last two backline spots

Ill have him or Heath, depends who is named :P

Imo out of the ones you suggested, Stevenson > Vlastuin > Colquhon :)

[tbagrocks]

Youngest player in the AFL, even if named will be vested and I couldn't imagine they would string enough games for him to make much cash

[Sapientia]

30 touches and 15 marks in the SANFL this week.

Just racks it up. Still no idea if he can defend though :p