First Draft Of team - Rate?

[Jake Bake A Cake]

Any thoughts so far, still undecided on parts....

DEF - Enright, Lake, Hodge, McPhee, Waite, Ladson, Fisher - Emg. Maguire and Trengove

MID - Ablett, Mitchell, Vince, Martin, Trengove, Morabito - Emg. Jetta and Shuey

RUC - Jolly and Hudson - Emg. Charman and Lobbe

FWD - Riewoldt, Brown, Higgins, Franklin, Tippett, Dangerfield, Ziebell - Emg. Gumbleton and Podsiadly

Cheers Guys.

[Resch]

Good start...

Which Fisher is it?  Check Waite after NAB Cup.

Might want to think about someone other than Hudson.  Consistent 60 scorer but is that what you want?

I'm not a fan of Tippett in the Fwds but if you might want MPP, it is your call.  Maybe consider Tippett in ruck, Lobbe forward and then someone with upside in forwards (Polkinghorne type)

7/10

[ando_10]

7.5/10

[Jake Bake A Cake]

Ok have gone through and really reworked the team. Not sure if its for the best but here goes

FWD Enright, Lake, Hodge, McMahon, Kennelly, Ladson, Goddard
-Emg. Davis, Trengrove

MID Ablett, Mitchell, Vince, Martin, Trengrove, Morabito
-Emg Bastinac, Shuey

RUC Jolly, Kreuzer
- Emg. McNamara, Lobbe

FWD N Riewoldt, Tapscott, Higgins, Franklin, Tippett, Dangerfield, Ziebell
-Emg. Dennis-lane, Podsiadly.

Still have $107, 800 left to spend....

Didnt really use any your advice on this one Resch cause i rearranged the team before reading your comment =S

Thoughts?

Cheers guys.

[Streisand]

Lake is a top 5 defender but he won't score high for supercoach

[Resch]

Agree on Lake.  McMahon is not necessarily in the Tiger's starting team either (I have a personal dislike of him, so maybe ignore me!).  Tweak your backs a little.

Use your money on your 7th forward.  Upgrade Tapscott.

Improved from the first one though....

[Prospector_1]

Which McMahon?

[Resch]

Going point - I barrack for Tiges so automatically thought Jordan McMuffin.

Scott McMahon would be OK.

[Jake Bake A Cake]

Thanks Resch and Streisand.

Any suggestions on a replacement for lake?

Its Jordan McMahon (Rich).

I was looking fo a replacemnt for Tapscott but given that id only have about 200,000 to spend i was unsure which direction to head. Downgrade somewhere else to get an established forward or do some research into the upcoming rookies. Advice?

[Jake Bake A Cake]

Would a possible swap for Lake be S McMohan? pretty much the same price and you did mention he was OK.

Only thoughts would be for $490,000 i should be looking at someone a tad bit more then ok....


Again fairly new to supercoach and its tricky to not pick players that you know play good each week but in the realm of supercoach dont score big points.

[HillHero13]

all good besides..

mcphee - never had him never will but might be good at freo but could get someone better...

and

hudson - not the type of ruckman that gets alot of points look for someone like hille that can go foward and kick goals aswell... not saying get hille but someone like him..

[Jake Bake A Cake]

Thanks for that HillHero but further down i posted a second mock up of the team which actually doesn't include McPhee or Hudson.

Does it look any better?