FanFooty's National Draft First Round Competition

[Toga]

It's funny how everyone say's Grundy is going to Port ( not that i beleive much of the dribble that comes out of their mouths )but Cornes and his puppet Rowe reckon tonight, that there is no way, Grundy is going to the Power. I realise Kane plays there, but i find that interesting. After watching his highlights package, i would be happy if we snared him

port could definitely do with someone of his talent, but with four 200cm+ blokes on your list there's definitely a chance you might pick someone like Mayes instead i think. unlikely you will pass him up given he is also a strong marking option up forwards, but there is a chance!

[Mr.Craig]

I don't know if MTTY will want to do this but I thought I'd post Callum Twomey's phantom draft at AFL.com and we can see how he fares against us...

Pick #1 - Lachie Whitfield (GWS)

Pick #2 - Jonathan O'Rourke (GWS)

Pick #3 - Lachie Plowman (GWS)

Pick #4 - Jimmy Toumpas (Melb)

Pick #5 - Oliver Wines (WB)

Pick #6 - Troy Menzel (WB)

Pick #7 - Sam Mayes (Port)

Pick #8 - Jackson Macare (Bris)

Pick #9 - Nick Vlastuin (Rich)

Pick #10 - Joe Daniher (Ess)

Pick #11 - Kristian Jaksch (Carl)

Pick #12 - Aidan Corr (GWS)

Pick #13 - Josh Simpson (GC)

Pick #14 - Brodie Grundy (GWS)

Pick #15 - Nathan Hrovat (NM)

Pick #16 - Taylor Garner (Geel)

Pick #17 - Tim O'Brien (Fre)

Pick #18 - Jake Stringer (Coll)

Pick #19 - Ben Kennedy (Coll)

Pick #20 - Mason Wood (Adel)

Pick #21 - Tom Clurey (Coll)

Pick #22 - Tim Membrey (WB)

Pick #23 - Jesse Lonergan (Syd)

[Tominator]

Grundy going at Pick 14 LOLLLLLL

Toumpas won't be passed up by GWS and Wines will be snapped up by Melbourne for sure

[Jroo]

Grundy going at Pick 14 LOLLLLLL

Toumpas won't be passed up by GWS and Wines will be snapped up by Melbourne for sure

Ther is actually a chance Toumpas could be passed up by GWS. And Grudny could definitely slip as far to 14, even if it's unlikely.
More realistically this is what could happen I reckon
1. Whitfield
2. Menzel
3. Plowman
4. Toumpas
5. Wines
6. O'Rourke
7. Mayes
8. Jacksch
9. Vlastuin
10. Daniher
11. Macrae
12. Grundy

[Tominator]

Grundy going at Pick 14 LOLLLLLL

Toumpas won't be passed up by GWS and Wines will be snapped up by Melbourne for sure

Ther is actually a chance Toumpas could be passed up by GWS. And Grudny could definitely slip as far to 14, even if it's unlikely.
More realistically this is what could happen I reckon
1. Whitfield
2. Menzel
3. Plowman
4. Toumpas
5. Wines
6. O'Rourke
7. Mayes
8. Jacksch
9. Vlastuin
10. Daniher
11. Macrae
12. Grundy

not sure why everybody has gone quiet on Grundy, he was the lock for Pick 3 not that long ago but now everybody is talking of him slipping out of the Top 10...? If that does happen then whoever gets him is getting away with murder

Vlastuin to 9 is the big late mail, not sure where that has come from but he would be a good fit for the Tigers

Don't think O'Rourke would go to GWS because they already have guys like Shiel, Coniglio, Treloar, Tyson, Whitfield, Hoskin-Elliot, Ward, Scully and Palmer, so I think GWS will take Whitfield and Toumpas but not O'Rourke

[Jroo]

Grundy going at Pick 14 LOLLLLLL

Toumpas won't be passed up by GWS and Wines will be snapped up by Melbourne for sure

Ther is actually a chance Toumpas could be passed up by GWS. And Grudny could definitely slip as far to 14, even if it's unlikely.
More realistically this is what could happen I reckon
1. Whitfield
2. Menzel
3. Plowman
4. Toumpas
5. Wines
6. O'Rourke
7. Mayes
8. Jacksch
9. Vlastuin
10. Daniher
11. Macrae
12. Grundy

not sure why everybody has gone quiet on Grundy, he was the lock for Pick 3 not that long ago but now everybody is talking of him slipping out of the Top 10...? If that does happen then whoever gets him is getting away with murder

Vlastuin to 9 is the big late mail, not sure where that has come from but he would be a good fit for the Tigers

Don't think O'Rourke would go to GWS because they already have guys like Shiel, Coniglio, Treloar, Tyson, Whitfield, Hoskin-Elliot, Ward, Scully and Palmer, so I think GWS will take Whitfield and Toumpas but not O'Rourke

Yer GWS won't take O'Rourke. Out of Plowman, Toumpas and Menzel for 2 and 3

[Tominator]

some talk that Garlett will not get picked up at all due to his off-field issues... apparently at least 10 clubs have put a line through his name and will not pick him under any circumstance.. if he does go somewhere then if that club can get him right they will have snared a bargain, as he is good enough to be Top 5 easily

[tbagrocks]

1. Whitefield - WS Lock
2. Toumpas - WS
3. Grundy - WS
4. Wines - Dee's
5. Stringer - WB
6. Mayes - WB
7. Menzel - PA Lock
8. Plowman - Lions
9. McRae - Tig
10. Daniher - Bom
11. Jaksch - Blues
12. O.Rouke - WS
13. T Smith - GC
14. Kennedy - WS
15. Membrey - NM Lock
16. Vlastuin - Cats
17. M Shaw - Freo
18. Wood - Mag
19. Cluery - Mag
20. Colquhoun - Crows Lock
21. Hrovat - Mag
22. Simpson - WB
23. O.Brien

[MTTY]

Pick #1 - Lachie Whitfield - GWS - Lock

Pick #2 - Jimmy Toumpas - GWS

Pick #3 - Lachie Plowman - GWS

Pick #4 - Oliver Wines - Melbourne

Pick #5 - Jonathan O'Rourke - Western Bulldogs

Pick #6 - Jake Stringer - Western Bulldogs

Pick #7 - Brodie Grundy - Port Adelaide

Pick #8 - Kristian Jaksch - Brisbane - Lock

Pick #9 - Nick Vlastuin - Richmond

Pick #10 - Joe Daniher - Essendon

Pick #11 - Aidan Corr - Carlton

Pick #12 - Troy Menzel - GWS - Lock

Pick #13 - Nathan Hrovat - GC

Pick #14 - Sam Mayes - GWS

Pick #15 - Ben Kennedy - North Melbourne

Pick #16 -  Jackson Macrae - Geelong

Pick #17 - Mason Shaw - Fremantle - Lock

Pick #18 - Dayle Garlett - Collingwood

Pick #19 - Tim Membrey - Collingwood

Pick #20 - Josh Simpson - Collingwood

Pick #21 - Taylor Garner - Western Bulldogs

Pick #22 - Tim O'Brien - Sydney

[MTTY]

Could everyone please delete and edit their new selections as Adelaide are now out of the first round.

[Mr.Craig]

I was going to make a couple of changes anyway, will do it later today.

[Nige]

Pick #1 - Lachie Whitfield (GWS) Lock
Pick #2 â€" Jono O'Rourke (GWS)
Pick #3 â€" Lachie Plowman (GWS)
Pick #4 â€" Jimmy Toumpas (MEL)
Pick #5 â€" Ollie Wines (WBD)
Pick #6 â€" Jake Stringer (WBD)
Pick #7 â€" Brodie Grundy (PTA)
Pick #8 - Kristian Jaksch (BRI) Lock
Pick #9 â€" Nick Vlastuin (RIC)
Pick #10- Joe Daniher F/S (ESS)
Pick #11 â€" Sam Mayes (CAR)
Pick #12 â€" Dayle Garlett (GWS) Lock
Pick #13 â€" Jackson Macrae (GCS)
Pick #14 â€" Troy Menzel (GWS)
Pick #15 -Tom Clurey (NTM)
Pick #16 â€" Ben Kennedy (GEE)
Pick #17 â€" Mason Shaw (FRE) Lock
Pick #18 â€" Tim Membrey (COL)
Pick #19 â€" Nathan Hrovat (COL)
Pick #20 â€" Aidan Corr (COL)
Pick #21 - Josh Simpson (WBD)
Pick #22 â€" Sam Colquhoun (SYD)

[Tominator]

Crows withdraw Pick 20 and 54 as a "gesture of goodwill".....

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/151451/default.aspx

[Capper]

dont really know what i am doing but i will have a go

Pick #1 - Lachie Whitfield (GWS)
Pick #2 - Lachie Plowman  (GWS)
Pick #3 - Jimmy Toumpas (GWS)
Pick #4 - Oliver Wines (Melb) - Lock
Pick #5 - Jonathan O'Rourke (WB)
Pick #6 - Nick Vlastuin (WB)
Pick #7 - Brodie Grundy (Port) - Lock
Pick #8 - Jake Stringer  (Bris)
Pick #9 - Jackson Macrae (Rich)
Pick #10 - Joe Daniher (Ess)
Pick #11 - Kristian Jaksch (Carl) - Lock
Pick #12 - Tom Clurey (GWS)
Pick #13 - Mason Shaw (GC)
Pick #14 - Nathan Wright (GWS)
Pick #15 - Nathan Hrovat  (NM)
Pick #16 - Tim Membrey (Geel)
Pick #17 - Sam Mayes (Fre)
Pick #18 - Dayle Garlett  (Coll) - Lock
Pick #19 - Nick Graham (Coll)
Pick #20 - Jesse Lonergan (Coll)
Pick #21 - Troy Menzel (WB)
Pick #22 - Josh Simpson (Syd)

[Tominator]

dont really know what i am doing but i will have a go

Pick #1 - Lachie Whitfield (GWS)
Pick #2 - Lachie Plowman  (GWS)
Pick #3 - Jimmy Toumpas (GWS)
Pick #4 - Oliver Wines (Melb) - Lock
Pick #5 - Jonathan O'Rourke (WB)
Pick #6 - Nick Vlastuin (WB)
Pick #7 - Brodie Grundy (Port) - Lock
Pick #8 - Jake Stringer  (Bris)
Pick #9 - Jackson Macrae (Rich)
Pick #10 - Joe Daniher (Ess)
Pick #11 - Kristian Jaksch (Carl) - Lock
Pick #12 - Tom Clurey (GWS)
Pick #13 - Mason Shaw (GC)
Pick #14 - Nathan Wright (GWS)
Pick #15 - Nathan Hrovat  (NM)
Pick #16 - Tim Membrey (Geel)
Pick #17 - Sam Mayes (Fre)
Pick #18 - Dayle Garlett  (Coll) - Lock
Pick #19 - Nick Graham (Coll)
Pick #20 - Jesse Lonergan (Coll)
Pick #21 - Troy Menzel (WB)
Pick #22 - Josh Simpson (Syd)

pretty good order but Mayes will go before 17   :)