Updated FanPlanner

Started by roti, October 24, 2012, 08:27:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

roti

Quote from: stew42 on November 02, 2012, 03:54:22 PM
Quote from: Sweetness on November 02, 2012, 01:33:21 PM
Quote from: stew42 on November 02, 2012, 01:19:17 PM
Backs: Very cookie-cutter. That's a good thing. A very solid line, with noone from this year's draft, meaning more JS. 9/10

Mids: Again, fairly cookie-cutter. Can't really go past Pendles and Murph at their prices. Ball will lead to an early upgrade, and your rooks are good, although I have a feeling that there might be a few mid rooks to explode in their first season... keep an eye out. This ranking would be 10/10, if you went Cotch=> GAJ. 9/10

Rucks: One thing I do like about your team is that you haven't gone Grundy/Daniher as automatic R3/4. Look at Billy Longer last year, was nowhere near good enough for R3 or 4 at his price. Whereas Daw and to a lesser extent Witts have had some time in the system to prove themselves. 9.5/10

Fwds: I'm turning away from Franklin in 2013 (you can see more in my comments in his player profile). Robbo and Zaha are underpriced for what they can do, but I wouldn't go Martin partially for this (http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/150658/default.aspx), and also because of some of his work last season. I'd rather jump on him if he does prove himself in 2013. Bock provides good DPP, but wait until Broughts is given F/B... LeCras is a lock. Your rooks are alright, Morton should get games, but don't expect 22, as he was replacing McGlynn during the finals series. I wouldn't expect a high average from Macaffer, as he seems a prime sub candidate, and I haven't heard much about Lee. Like your mids, try and look for some rooks from the draft... 8.5/10

Overall: This is a really good team, just look around for some good rooks in the draft (with the exception of in your backs, you need all the JS you can get!)  9/10

I agree with Stew, very solid team. There's only 5 players different between my team at the moment too  8)

Stew you mentioned him going Cotch to GAJ, pretty sure he already has GAJ in there... :P
My bad, meant Swan :D Also, in case anyone's interested, our differences are that I don't have: Birchall, Docherty, Murphy, Ball, Crouch, Viney, Witts (although a similar type of player...), Franklin, Martin, Bock, Macaffer, Morton or Lee. But I also have left $157k in the cap

haha most of those are rookies i am by no means set on and the others are the ones i can see first changing around, freaky