This or That? - Directory

[KoopKicka]

So, I have no idea whether something happened like this last season, but this is basically a comparison, like a player profile, but on 2 people, and who you should take, like Ball vs Embley, or Roughead vs Ryder, or Birchall vs Suckling (for example) so yeah, I will start this, feel free to join in, please try and hyperlink, but its not the end of the world. :)

Defenders:

Nathan Bock vs Jarrod Harbrow (Toga)



Midfielders

Luke Ball vs Andrew Embley (KoopKicka)
Trent Cotchin vs Mark Murphy (Toga)
Trent Cotchin vs Brett Deledio (Toga)
Dane Swan vs Dayne Beams vs Scott Pendlebury (Toga)
Dane Swan vs Gary Ablett Jnr (Toga)





Ruckmen:

Todd Goldstein vs Nic Natianui (elephants)

Forwards:

Mark LeCras vs Robbie Gray (Adamant)
Matty Wright vs Clancee Pearce vs David Zaharakis (elephants)
Lance Franklin vs Steve Johnson (Adamant)

[stew42]

Great idea! To kick things off, Goldy or NicNat?

[Hagebear]

I'm struggling with Cotchin v Murphy?

[elephants]

Matthew Wright vs Clancee Pearce :)

[Footy_Boiz]

Matthew Wright vs Clancee Pearce :)

V Sylvia, trying to decide out of those three for a spot

[elephants]

Matthew Wright vs Clancee Pearce :)

V Sylvia, trying to decide out of those three for a spot

V Zaharakis lol

[Ajax22]

Is the idea to make separate threads for each of these battles and then have them linked in the original post? Or are we supposed to give thoughts on all the battles in this thread?

[Jukes]

Great idea! To kick things off, Goldy or NicNat?

Goldy by a country mile.

I'm struggling with Cotchin v Murphy?

Murphy. Underpriced and I can only see Cotch outscoring him by >5 points.

Matthew Wright vs Clancee Pearce :)

Neither TBH

I'd prefer Clokey over Sylvia, Zacka, Pearce and Wright by a long way.

[Adamant]

Matthew Wright vs Clancee Pearce :)

V Sylvia, trying to decide out of those three for a spot

V Zaharakis lol

Zaha definitely out of those options IMO. He was averaging 90+ before he tore his quad, and his injury lowered his average down to 83...underpriced!

[KoopKicka]

Is the idea to make separate threads for each of these battles and then have them linked in the original post? Or are we supposed to give thoughts on all the battles in this thread?

seperate topics. :)

[Justin Bieber]

Robbie Gray vs Mark Lecras

And other cheap fwd options.

Maybe Brodie Grundy vs Nathan Vardy

[Ziplock]

Great idea! To kick things off, Goldy or NicNat?

Both- Nic Nat should keep improving, a little because of the ruck rule change, a lot more from more rucking time and natural progression, while goldy without nic nat should fire. Grab both, watch them pump out 90-100 then have leuen chillin' on the bench :P

[Ajax22]

Great idea! To kick things off, Goldy or NicNat?

Both- Nic Nat should keep improving, a little because of the ruck rule change, a lot more from more rucking time and natural progression, while goldy without nic nat should fire. Grab both, watch them pump out 90-100 then have leuen chillin' on the bench :P

250k feels pretty wasted on a bench player

As a choice I like Goldy over Nic Nat tho

[Adamant]

Mark LeCras vs Robbie Gray (Adamant)

[tbagrocks]

Bock v Staker