Youngy gone, What compo should we recicive

Started by Hawka, October 19, 2012, 12:58:06 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Hawka

Well its just come through Youngy has signed a 3 year deal for the pies
Bit disapointed but not the biggest loss and i reckon we can cover
Im keen to see what Compo we get i really think an end of first round pick is in order

Spite

Quote from: Hawka on October 19, 2012, 12:58:06 AM
Well its just come through Youngy has signed a 3 year deal for the pies
Bit disapointed but not the biggest loss and i reckon we can cover
Im keen to see what Compo we get i really think an end of first round pick is in order

End of first round?!?

Goddard worth mid first round therefore young would be worth something along the lines of end of second round pick.

Also, go pies! :P

Hawka

Quote from: Spite on October 19, 2012, 01:00:07 AM
Quote from: Hawka on October 19, 2012, 12:58:06 AM
Well its just come through Youngy has signed a 3 year deal for the pies
Bit disapointed but not the biggest loss and i reckon we can cover
Im keen to see what Compo we get i really think an end of first round pick is in order

End of first round?!?

Goddard worth mid first round therefore young would be worth something along the lines of end of second round pick.

Also, go pies! :P
Dont forget Murphy who will be atleast 3rd round before Young comes into calcualtions
If Sam Reid from the dogs was a 3rd round compo pick then surely! Murphy is the same or better and Young is an 100 game Prem player who played 20 games this year, surely together it will come close to end of first round

Spite

Quote from: Hawka on October 19, 2012, 01:04:04 AM
Quote from: Spite on October 19, 2012, 01:00:07 AM
Quote from: Hawka on October 19, 2012, 12:58:06 AM
Well its just come through Youngy has signed a 3 year deal for the pies
Bit disapointed but not the biggest loss and i reckon we can cover
Im keen to see what Compo we get i really think an end of first round pick is in order

End of first round?!?

Goddard worth mid first round therefore young would be worth something along the lines of end of second round pick.

Also, go pies! :P
Dont forget Murphy who will be atleast 3rd round before Young comes into calcualtions
If Sam Reid from the dogs was a 3rd round compo pick then surely! Murphy is the same or better and Young is an 100 game Prem player who played 20 games this year, surely together it will come close to end of first round

Got a feeling this free agency will make them more stingy with compo picks!

Ziplock


Justin Bieber


Ziplock


Mr.Craig

Mark Stevens‏@StevoHeraldSun

Hawks' Mark Evans re Young: "It is like we've been pick-pocketed and somebody has put an old $2 scratchy ticket back in our pocket."

Ziplock


JBs-Hawks

Danyle pearce and Chaplin definitely worth 30 picks better than young  ::)

Croc of shower

henry

Absolute bull. You could argue Murphy was better then Pearce, yet losing him and Young gives us a pick 30 after  ::). I heard the Hawks are looking for a way to appeal, I hope we do. Very unfair.

Tyes

I can understand getting nothing for Murph (not that I don't rate him just the fact he was a depth player and not in the 22) but Young should have been a 2nd round pick. The 3rd round pick only looks horrible because we finished top, but I do agree that Young was most certainly worth a second rounder.

Mr.Craig


Hawka

THIS IS CRAP! how the hell is Young rated 30 less then Pearce or Chaplin, IDC about there formula, its clear Young should have a better pick then what we got

Ziplock

I think it's because you got lake in free agency. It's basically saying that lake + 60 = young.

I think that's how they're doing it...