HMac trade official

[JBs-Hawks]

north got screwed lol.

hmac was cleared by geelongs medical staff- when fit he's an AA ruckman, he was worth at least a pick in the 20s minimum.

i think he is worth pick 15, but to north he isnt worth much. So 36 is better than nothing.

Yea you guys were a year too late with trading him. Probably could have got a first rounder last year with Port/gws/tigers bidding on hints but this year he was always leaving and only possible suitor was the cats

[monstrum]

Well they didnt hav pick 22 did they, they had 15 and 36

[Mailman the 2nd]

Well they didnt hav pick 22 did they, they had 15 and 36

If I was Longmuire? Coach of the Sydney Swans?

He won a premiership like 3 weeks ago lol

[Holz]

Well they didnt hav pick 22 did they, they had 15 and 36

If I was Longmuire? Coach of the Sydney Swans?

He won a premiership like 3 weeks ago lol

would be stuck behind mummy, Hmac just isnt a good 2nd back Im not sure if they would have done that out of respect to Hmac.

[Mailman the 2nd]

Well they didnt hav pick 22 did they, they had 15 and 36

If I was Longmuire? Coach of the Sydney Swans?

He won a premiership like 3 weeks ago lol

would be stuck behind mummy, Hmac just isnt a good 2nd back Im not sure if they would have done that out of respect to Hmac.

Fair point actually

What happens with West then though?

[monstrum]

Well they didnt hav pick 22 did they, they had 15 and 36

If I was Longmuire? Coach of the Sydney Swans?

He won a premiership like 3 weeks ago lol

Its john longmire, not longmuire..

When u said longmuire i just figgured one of the longmuires were involved at the cats

[Mailman the 2nd]

Well they didnt hav pick 22 did they, they had 15 and 36

If I was Longmuire? Coach of the Sydney Swans?

He won a premiership like 3 weeks ago lol

Its john longmire, not longmuire..

When u said longmuire i just figgured one of the longmuires were involved at the cats

Yeah.......

[monstrum]

Why did longmire and sydney even get brought up anyway  ???

Was there talk he'd go to the swans?

[Mailman the 2nd]

Why did longmire and sydney even get brought up anyway  ???

Was there talk he'd go to the swans?

It isn't that hard, just look at page 1 of the thread.

North got screwed pretty big in that trade.

If I was Longmuire I would've offered at least pick 22 lol

I was saying how they got screwed over

[roo boys!]

north got screwed lol.

hmac was cleared by geelongs medical staff- when fit he's an AA ruckman, he was worth at least a pick in the 20s minimum.

i think he is worth pick 15, but to north he isnt worth much. So 36 is better than nothing.

Yea you guys were a year too late with trading him. Probably could have got a first rounder last year with Port/gws/tigers bidding on hints but this year he was always leaving and only possible suitor was the cats

Yup. We were keen to see how the combo went with Goldy so I suppose that's fair enought that we tried it out...never know until you try it.

[kilbluff1985]

yep North got screwed should have been Pick 36 and and a young player or something

[Holz]

Have a little read of this.

http://www.kangaroos.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/4912/newsid/149977/default.aspx

McDonald does bring up some good points, while im sure they would have liked more for him i defintatley think its is a good long term move.