HMac trade official

[roo boys!]

Traded to Geelong for pick 36. Personally I think we were ripped off but I'm always going to overvalue North players I suppose.

[Torpedo10]

Traded to Geelong for pick 36. Personally I think we were ripped off but I'm always going to overvalue North players I suppose.

You were ripped off.  :-X

[Jroo]

Traded to Geelong for pick 36. Personally I think we were ripped off but I'm always going to overvalue North players I suppose.

Win-Win for both clubs. Geelong could do with another ruckmen while this opens the Daw for Majak  8) and Goldy to play as the first ruckmen the whole time. Pick 36 is alright and I reckon it's a fair trade

[Holz]

While Gellong got a great deal and he should have gone for much more, we really didnt need him and getting him off the list helps our long term development.

[Jroo]

While Gellong got a great deal and he should have gone for much more, we really didnt need him and getting him off the list helps our long term development.

He is 28 years old.
He has only played 8 games in the last 2 years so he has some injury concerns.
But when he is on the park he is a quality player and would be worth a lot more if it wasnt for the injury concerns

[monstrum]

Traded to Geelong for pick 36. Personally I think we were ripped off but I'm always going to overvalue North players I suppose.

It does feel that way dosnt it! Ptobly didnt help he's been injured last 2 years..

Will anyone be considerrung hmac in their sides next tear?

[Jroo]

Traded to Geelong for pick 36. Personally I think we were ripped off but I'm always going to overvalue North players I suppose.

It does feel that way dosnt it! Ptobly didnt help he's been injured last 2 years..

Will anyone be considerrung hmac in their sides next tear?

He won't be cheap though. He will nearly be $500k according to fan planner in SC

[monstrum]

Oh, i thought he would be less

[Holz]

Traded to Geelong for pick 36. Personally I think we were ripped off but I'm always going to overvalue North players I suppose.

It does feel that way dosnt it! Ptobly didnt help he's been injured last 2 years..

Will anyone be considerrung hmac in their sides next tear?

definitely not, Goldy is cheaper and will average 95+ in DT and 105+ in SC. I dont even have to think about it, he is in my sqaud if fit.

[Capper]

If he stays at North then North will only play him up front as they have said that they wont use him as a ruckman.

If he goes to the cats then he will be used more as a ruckman than a forward.

I think he will score more at the cats but as North dont wont him to ruck due to his injuries he might not get the game time he would playing forward.

I dont like him as a option at either club

i wrote this on Hmac's player profile by Le, and i still think it is a worry. Can he hold up??

[Holz]

If he stays at North then North will only play him up front as they have said that they wont use him as a ruckman.

If he goes to the cats then he will be used more as a ruckman than a forward.

I think he will score more at the cats but as North dont wont him to ruck due to his injuries he might not get the game time he would playing forward.

I dont like him as a option at either club

i wrote this on Hmac's player profile by Le, and i still think it is a worry. Can he hold up??

I think he will, there is a chance he could be as good for them as Maric was for richmond. I wish him the best and just hope he has an off game when he plays against goldy.

[Ziplock]

north got screwed lol.

hmac was cleared by geelongs medical staff- when fit he's an AA ruckman, he was worth at least a pick in the 20s minimum.

[monstrum]

Geelong only had pick 15 & 36

Funny that dawes went for pick 20 i think..?

[Holz]

north got screwed lol.

hmac was cleared by geelongs medical staff- when fit he's an AA ruckman, he was worth at least a pick in the 20s minimum.

i think he is worth pick 15, but to north he isnt worth much. So 36 is better than nothing.

[Mailman the 2nd]

North got screwed pretty big in that trade.

If I was Longmuire I would've offered at least pick 22 lol