2013 Player Profile: Jonathan Giles

[Adamant]

His resigning makes me a bit more keen. I think he could be vulnerable to a Zac Smith type year this year...

He shouldnt drop off like Smith did.
Dont forget Smith is only 22, whereas Giles has been in the system for 4 years and is 25 himself.

[Shihan7]

Better options around.

[timmyparso]

smokey, smokey, smokey.......................

[Hagebear]

smokey, smokey, smokey.......................

+1 I can see him averaging 90. No competition for his spot. Doesn't spend much time on the bench, goes forward and kicks goals, plus the Giants slightly improving.

[Money]

Awesome pick at 100k, Shouldnt even think about it at 420k

[pommyadam]

can't see why not
after Cox (who most people have in the forwards) and Maric, there's not many good ruck options out there

for a 400k ruck, they're all very similar, can't see too many differences between Giles/Minson/Kruezer (from a DT perspective)
that, and he got an 89 against the Lions Longer/Berger/Martin ruck combo last week

won't make my side, but wouldn't completely rule him out of appearing in some teams

[Football Factory]

He will appear in my Fantasy Elite team  ;)

[/////////////////////////]

gun player and he will be better in his 2nd year