Re: WXV Trade Confirmation Thread & Final Draft Order

[ossie85]

Sorry for the big delay guys, we have all 18 coaches votes in:

Trade   N
65   0
66   0
67   1
68   0
69   4
70   0
71   1
72   0
73   0
74   8
75   2
76   1
77   1
78   1
79   0
80   0
81   0
82   0
83   1


The Zorko trade votes against: bomberboy0618, FisherSaints, Hellopplz, MajorLazer, meow meow, ossie85, Purple 77, roo boys!

Reasons - Gibson is old and hasn't shown potential, Wood might be delisted and the pick does not get near the value of Zorko

[FisherSaints]

I didn't go against my trade

[ossie85]

I didn't go against my trade

^ your assistant did, and you didn't vote...

[FisherSaints]

Ah OK

[CrowsFan]

I didn't go against my trade

^ your assistant did, and you didn't vote...

MUTINY!! :o

[bomberboy0618]

I've gotta be honest, some of the deals Tbag has done are a bit dodgy.

[CrowsFan]

Considering you're the head coach I reckon you could say they don't count ;)

[ossie85]

Considering you're the head coach I reckon you could say they don't count ;)

Disagree, if bomberboy gave tbag the right to do some trading, then the same rules should apply. Both parties need to cancel the trade.

If bomberboy didn't give him the right though, then all trades are null and void.

I think that's fair?

[CrowsFan]

Yeah that's fair. Considering BB was going away till friday if he had said something like "get some trades done whilst I'm gone" then they should count, but if he said something like "see if you can work out some possible trades whilst I'm gone" then they shouldn't count...

[bomberboy0618]

Considering you're the head coach I reckon you could say they don't count ;)

Disagree, if bomberboy gave tbag the right to do some trading, then the same rules should apply. Both parties need to cancel the trade.

If bomberboy didn't give him the right though, then all trades are null and void.

I think that's fair?

I got him to fill the role I would have, which is to make  some trades yes.

[Boomz]

Sorry for the big delay guys, we have all 18 coaches votes in:

Trade   N
65   0
66   0
67   1
68   0
69   4
70   0
71   1
72   0
73   0
74   8
75   2
76   1
77   1
78   1
79   0
80   0
81   0
82   0
83   1


The Zorko trade votes against: bomberboy0618, FisherSaints, Hellopplz, MajorLazer, meow meow, ossie85, Purple 77, roo boys!

Reasons - Gibson is old and hasn't shown potential, Wood might be delisted and the pick does not get near the value of Zorko

Thought I voted against it?  :-X

[ossie85]

Yeah you did, sorry Boomz!

[bomberboy0618]

Ringo and I have reached a deal over Sidey giving us the best for our future.
London gives: Laird, Gorringe and Mackie
Beijing gives: Sidebottom
Reason: We are going for the future, and Laird and Gorringe have potential. Mackie has experience so will score well.

[CrowsFan]

Pretty sure the deal I offered you was better than that...

[Ringo]

Ringo and I have reached a deal over Sidey giving us the best for our future.
London gives: Laird, Gorringe and Mackie
Beijing gives: Sidebottom
Reason: We are going for the future, and Laird and Gorringe have potential. Mackie has experience so will score well.

Confirmed
Reasoning - Opportunity arose to acquire a premium player which the Royals desperately need and Sidebottom fills this role.  Maybe even Captain material for the Royals as he is still relatively young.
To gain a premium there will be sacrifices and in this regard we are sorry to be losing Mackie a very consistent backman. Laird an up and coming defender and Gorringe who looks to be starting to fulfill his promise. These three players for a player of Sidebottom class is considered fair.