who is the best 6th defender from this bunch?

Started by christoff, February 18, 2010, 04:05:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

who is the best 6th defender from this bunch?

jay nash
1 (6.7%)
mark nicoski
1 (6.7%)
tadhg kennelly
6 (40%)
rick ladson
6 (40%)
beau waters
1 (6.7%)

Total Members Voted: 3

christoff

hey guys im not sure who i want to b my 6th defender out of these guys id love to get beau waters coz hes the cheapest but i think jay nash could have a good yr with port he found abit of the ball for essendon a few yrs ago and could b a risk that pays off nicely for me... what are your thoughts on it?

mcwarne

Well definitely not the first two. However you might want to consider all 3 of the others as 5, 6 and 7. At this stage I have Kennelly, Hunt and Waters as the last 3 but Ladson is a chance if he starts getting better scores in the Nab. Waters is set to play for WC in their next game.

christoff

i have nash now but if waters gets through the game i will change it i think that will free up 50k for me thanks.

christoff


Justin Bieber

great kick but doesn't tackle enough for a defender.

between kennelly and nash for me.

christoff

between kennelly and nash for me also but i wanna b different and pick nash

nas

Psst:- Looks like you're minds made up so pick Nash

christoff

any1 think nash will play games 4 port this yr coz if he does i think he could average around 60 - 70 thoughts?

Justin Bieber

might be a chance for the early rounds. one of the defenders are suspended (forgot who). if he plays well enough might stick around for a bit.

Selwood4brownlow

thanks so much for this. was just about to post the same thing