All Time Footy Draft Game, best 18!

[tbagrocks]

Ok well that's it! Well played everyone it has been very enjoyable, though we still need Mailman to pick his final two players the draft is over

Please post your final teams here and the judges can have a look and work out how to decide! I believe they are JB's Hawks and Sid

[quinny88]

Ok well that's it! Well played everyone it has been very enjoyable, though we still need Mailman to pick his final two players the draft is over

Please post your final teams here and the judges can have a look and work out how to decide! I believe they are JB's Hawks and Sid

Is that the only 2 deciding tbag? I think we should all vote 3,2,1 on which team we like best (obviously cant vote our own team) Or maybe even just 1 point to second favourite team, 2 points to favourite team. Some sort of system like that anyway. Just gives a broader view on which team comes out on top.
Its up to you though, your draft :)

[tbagrocks]

That's interesting, how does this sound, JB and Sid each elvaluate the teams out of ten, and the six coaches vote 3-2-1 on their choice as best team not counting their own, the scores added together for each team to determine a winner

also I was thinking of putting the teams in the FB and opening up a poll for the public to vote, but that could be seperate!

[13Brummy]

My full team:

Fwd:           Norm Smith                Gary Ablett Snr                 Matthew Pavlich

H fwd:         Darrel Baldock           Dermott Brereton              Lance Franklin

Mid:            Ben Cousins               Russell Ebert                     Shane Crawford

H back:       Nathan Buckley          Chris Grant                        Bruce Doull

Back:          Syd Coventry             Steven Silvagni                  Ivor Warne-Smith

Foll:            Jim Stynes                 Chris Judd                         Bill Hutchison

[quinny88]

That's interesting, how does this sound, JB and Sid each elvaluate the teams out of ten, and the six coaches vote 3-2-1 on their choice as best team not counting their own, the scores added together for each team to determine a winner

also I was thinking of putting the teams in the FB and opening up a poll for the public to vote, but that could be seperate!

Yeah sounds good to me mate, but like I said its your draft

[Kellogscrunchynut]

It's been a pleasure partaking in this draft with you guys like I said earlier it's the first that I've ever done and things didn't always go as planned, although I never ran out of ideas for places. Tried to mix it up with eras and was at one stage considering a VFA player from the 1870's, worked more or less with some decades being more favored than others.

[Mailman the 2nd]

I'll be picking my two soon  :)

[Mailman the 2nd]

I'll pick up Todd Viney and Jack Mueller

Back: Gary Ayres,  Jack Regan, John Nicholls

H-Back: John Rantall,   Paul Roos,  Brendon Goddard ,

Centre: Michael Aish, Gary Ablett Jnr., Robert DiPierdomenico

H-Forward: Todd Viney, Ted Whitten Snr, Jack Mueller

Forward: Malcom Blight, Gordon Coventry, Brad Johnson

[quinny88]

I'll pick up Todd Viney and Jack Mueller

Back: Gary Ayres,  Jack Regan, John Nicholls

H-Back: John Rantall,   Paul Roos,  Brendon Goddard ,

Centre: Michael Aish, Gary Ablett Jnr., Robert DiPierdomenico

H-Forward: Todd Viney, Ted Whitten Snr, Jack Mueller

Forward: Malcom Blight, Gordon Coventry, Brad Johnson

You're missing a line

[Mailman the 2nd]

So I am

Back: Gary Ayres,  Jack Regan, John Nicholls

H-Back: John Rantall,   Paul Roos,  Brendon Goddard ,

Centre: Michael Aish, Gary Ablett Jnr., Robert DiPierdomenico

H-Forward: Todd Viney, Ted Whitten Snr, Jack Mueller

Forward: Malcom Blight, Gordon Coventry, Brad Johnson

Followers: Jack Dyer, Garry McIntosh, Barry Cable

[Kellogscrunchynut]

For a second I thought you were talking about the young Viney.

[Mailman the 2nd]

haha you wish :P

[tbagrocks]

All the teams are posted on Pg 21, 22 and Mons pg 20

So I will get JB and Sid to score each team out of 10, and the rest of us to give a vote of 3-2-1 to the teams you think are best not including your own, maybe do it via pm to me to keep it not bias

[quinny88]

Just posting all of the teams below so I can see them all in the same place and compare them :)

Team: Mailman the 2nd

Back: Gary Ayres,  Jack Regan, John Nicholls

H-Back: John Rantall,   Paul Roos,  Brendon Goddard ,

Centre: Michael Aish, Gary Ablett Jnr., Robert DiPierdomenico

H-Forward: Todd Viney, Ted Whitten Snr, Jack Mueller

Forward: Malcom Blight, Gordon Coventry, Brad Johnson

Followers: Jack Dyer, Garry McIntosh, Barry Cable



Team: 13Brummy

Fwd:           Norm Smith                Gary Ablett Snr                 Matthew Pavlich

H fwd:         Darrel Baldock           Dermott Brereton              Lance Franklin

Mid:            Ben Cousins               Russell Ebert                     Shane Crawford

H back:       Nathan Buckley          Chris Grant                        Bruce Doull

Back:          Syd Coventry             Steven Silvagni                  Ivor Warne-Smith

Foll:            Jim Stynes                 Chris Judd                         Bill Hutchison



Team: tbagrocks

Gavin Wanganeen - Vic Thorp - Glenn Archer

Andrew McLeod - Graham Cornes - Walter Scott

Peter Carey - Fos Williams - Ron Barassi

Michael Tuck - Paul Kelly - Gary Hocking

Jason Akermanis - Barrie Robran - Kevin Bartlett

Darren Jarman - John Coleman - Rick Davies



Team: Kellogscrunchynut

B:   Bernie Smith        Matthew Scarlett      Harold Rumney

HB:  Reg Hickey        Albert Collier         Kevin Murray

C:    Francis Bourke   -   Lindsey Head   -    Craig Bradley

HF:  Matthew Richardson  -  Royce Hart  -    Albert Thurgood

FF:  Bob Pratt  -  Ken Farmer      Peter Hudson

Foll: Roy Wright - Ian Stewart - Dick Reynolds.



Team: quinny88

B:   Dustin Fletcher      Geoff Southby       Kevin Sheedy

HB: Guy McKenna        Glen Jakovich         Trevor Barker

C:    Peter Matera       Greg Williams         Doug Hawkins

HF:  Alex Jesaulenko    Steven Kernahan   Michael Voss
 
FF:  Leigh Matthews     Jason Dunstall       Steven Milne

Foll: Simon Madden      Bob Skilton           Haydn Bunton Snr



Team: monstrum

FB:        D.Dench       D.Glass       C.Enright

HB:        L.Hodge       P.Knights     J.Bartel

C:          S.Black        A.Goodes      K.Grieg

HF:      M.Ricciuto      W.Carey        J.Hird

FF:        J.Brown        T.Lockett     P.Daicos

FOL:     G.Farmer      R.Harvey      J.Platten

[quinny88]

Soo.. do we have a winner?