rate and comments/opinions please.

Started by ando_10, February 17, 2010, 02:12:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ando_10

backs: goddard enright hodge kenelly hunt ladson waters....davis trengove

mids: ablett dal santo goodes vince trengove martin.....shuey bastinac

rucks: jolly tippet....lobbe mcnamara

forward:reiwoldt pav okeefe higgins dangerfield burton rockliffe....dennis lane podsiadly

lozza63

Ando did you steal some money for this team? The forwards are so deep too
I like it man a lot - put Goodes in the forwards and Danger in the mids as the trade up target - yep tip - top
Maybe one small whinge - the filler in the rucks, but if you need one it may as well be there - just leave as it is (keep an eye out for Beau - otherwise Maguire could fill a spot for a little while!
9.25/10 my highest score yet!

ando_10

:) thanks dude means alot. yeah good point ill chuck danger in there and goodes down forward :)

Wild Thing

Very decent side to start with.  Only concern I see is the possibility of a lean backline score with your returning players this year if they take a while to get going (Ladson, Kenelly, Hunt & Waters).  Overall, looks like a very good starting team.  One more ruckmen on the bench that will probably play is about the only other thing I might suggest.

ando_10

cheers wildthing
yeah im a bit stuck with my backline they will all like up round one but just the matter of what shape they will be in got any suggestions.

Wild Thing

ando, I wouldn't change too much, bear in mind that each of those players will increase in value significantly providing they play consistently so you have a lot of trade up options by about Round 7-8.  I'd strongly consider leaving them in at this stage and cashing in and upgrading about a third of the way into the season.

ando_10

cheers wild thing ill leave it i think :)

Hondo71

Obviously picking all 4 of Kennelly, Hunt, Ladson and Waters frees up a lot of cash to spend elsewhere.

It's a risk, but who knows it could work out great for you. 

Kennelly I see as less of a risk than the other 3.  Waters makes me the most nervous of the other 3.  You don't want early zeroes.

Hondo71

The alternative approach which may be just as risky is to put another rookie starting in the midfield and then pick a more durable defender.

ossie85


Geez that's a good team. Fitting Ablett, Dal, Goodes and Vince in the same midfield?! Impressive.

I'd think about putting Goodes in the forward line, get rid of burton, pick another rockie up in the centre, and use the extra $100k to upgrade a backmen.

But seriously, well done.

ando_10

thanks guys ossie85 who ya think i should throw in the mid as a cheap option? i already have trengove and martin.

HillHero13

i'm no ossie85 but i think either masten or mcveigh who i think will rise too 500k+

ando_10


Colty

Thats a cracker team, like others have Said not sure about Waters, but apart form that like it alot.

just give up

remember, the match's in supercoach dont start till round 4 or 5? so that will give them a couple of rounds to get some form.