Main Menu

Brian Lake

Started by meow meow, October 01, 2012, 02:24:24 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Ziplock

I did say that if they played like they did against adelaide, they wouldn't win against sydney...

and they did, so they didn't.

Hawka

Im just worried if Shoecy dosent bulk up much
They said hawks is the team to play to get your outta form big forwards into form which sure Cloke get 6 and Tippet get 4, im just worried it may cost us games

quinny88

Quote from: Hawka on October 02, 2012, 09:16:50 PM
Im just worried if Shoecy dosent bulk up much
They said hawks is the team to play to get your outta form big forwards into form which sure Cloke get 6 and Tippet get 4, im just worried it may cost us games

You finished top of the ladder and lost the GF by 10 points which was not a result of Sydneys full forward dominance. Hasnt cost you much so far, dont think it will start. Fair enough looking for a new back if yo think schoey needs a hand but lake is not that man imo

Hawka

Quote from: quinny88 on October 02, 2012, 10:18:25 PM
Quote from: Hawka on October 02, 2012, 09:16:50 PM
Im just worried if Shoecy dosent bulk up much
They said hawks is the team to play to get your outta form big forwards into form which sure Cloke get 6 and Tippet get 4, im just worried it may cost us games

You finished top of the ladder and lost the GF by 10 points which was not a result of Sydneys full forward dominance. Hasnt cost you much so far, dont think it will start. Fair enough looking for a new back if yo think schoey needs a hand but lake is not that man imo
Yeah maybe he isnt the man, but Adelaide got very close to knocking us over with alot of help from Tippet and Walker

quinny88

Quote from: Hawka on October 02, 2012, 10:20:12 PM
Quote from: quinny88 on October 02, 2012, 10:18:25 PM
Quote from: Hawka on October 02, 2012, 09:16:50 PM
Im just worried if Shoecy dosent bulk up much
They said hawks is the team to play to get your outta form big forwards into form which sure Cloke get 6 and Tippet get 4, im just worried it may cost us games

You finished top of the ladder and lost the GF by 10 points which was not a result of Sydneys full forward dominance. Hasnt cost you much so far, dont think it will start. Fair enough looking for a new back if yo think schoey needs a hand but lake is not that man imo
Yeah maybe he isnt the man, but Adelaide got very close to knocking us over with alot of help from Tippet and Walker

Alot of help from Hawthorn missing goals more like it. Should have buried Adelaide if they kicked straight

Ricochet

Quote from: quinny88 on October 02, 2012, 11:15:53 PM
Quote from: Hawka on October 02, 2012, 10:20:12 PM
Quote from: quinny88 on October 02, 2012, 10:18:25 PM
Quote from: Hawka on October 02, 2012, 09:16:50 PM
Im just worried if Shoecy dosent bulk up much
They said hawks is the team to play to get your outta form big forwards into form which sure Cloke get 6 and Tippet get 4, im just worried it may cost us games

You finished top of the ladder and lost the GF by 10 points which was not a result of Sydneys full forward dominance. Hasnt cost you much so far, dont think it will start. Fair enough looking for a new back if yo think schoey needs a hand but lake is not that man imo
Yeah maybe he isnt the man, but Adelaide got very close to knocking us over with alot of help from Tippet and Walker

Alot of help from Hawthorn missing goals more like it. Should have buried Adelaide if they kicked straight
and should have won on saturday if they didn't miss the ones they did

Torpedo10

I wouldn't go for Lake. Keep on Schoey and if you can get a young KPD then fine but not someone as old as Lake.......Unless it's Fletch.  :P

quinny88

Quote from: Torpedo10 on October 02, 2012, 11:28:56 PM
I wouldn't go for Lake. Keep on Schoey and if you can get a young KPD then fine but not someone as old as Lake.......Unless it's Fletch.  :P

Fletch is old enough to be Lakes dad.. Haha

henry

Quote from: Torpedo10 on October 02, 2012, 11:28:56 PM
I wouldn't go for Lake. Keep on Schoey and if you can get a young KPD then fine but not someone as old as Lake.......Unless it's Fletch.  :P
I've heard rumours about Mitch Brown from WCE wanting to leave and it would be great if we could get him, I really like him as a player. However he's not a free agent and West Coast wouldn't want him to leave, plus I think he may be contracted.

Scrads

Quote from: Hawka on October 02, 2012, 09:16:50 PM
Im just worried if Shoecy dosent bulk up much
They said hawks is the team to play to get your outta form big forwards into form which sure Cloke get 6 and Tippet get 4, im just worried it may cost us games

The good thing for us is that when these happened, we won those games anyway.

Tyes

Quote from: quinny88 on October 02, 2012, 06:38:43 PM
Nah this is just not the answer imo.
Hawthorn were the best side all season, they didnt get over the line on the big day but it wasnt because Sydneys full forward tore you apart and kicked 8. Dont need a bloke on the wrong side of 30 that hasnt been near his best for 3 years

This.
We lost the game because our midfielders didnt run both ways and we got sliced up through the middle. Birch and Suckers were stopped, our game plan was exposed and we did not kick straight. All this hype about a 'gorilla defender' won't stop that.
Shoey will be better for another year under his belt and Lake is just getting on. While I wouldnt completly be against getting Lake, to give up any pick before the 3rd round would be foolish IMO.

the flying hawk

I think this would be the best move ever! not is he just a great defender he would be great for schoenmakers development. And would strenghthen the backline yeah so what he is 30 defenders can go for longer than mids and the hawks are what he needs to get that spark back in his game and the hawks will need him for as liong as the premiership window is open i say go for it for the teams success hangs in the balance!

Capper

just heard on the trade radio that this is a done deal

Waiting for details

Ricochet

#28
yep

Michael Gleeson ‏@mickgleeson
Brian Lake to Hawthorn for first round pick. paper work being done now

and this as well

Sam Edmund ‏@SammyHeraldSun
Believe Deal is Lake & No.27 to Hawks for 21 & 41.

Cicjose