Guess Scrads' 2013 Smokie (a tribute to PB and Sam Blease 2012)

Started by Scrads, September 12, 2012, 12:52:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Scrads

Hey guys some of you may remember last year PB had a running 'Smokie' which he made us try and guess over the pre-season. Eventually it was let out that his smokie was Sam Blease.

Anyway this year I am going to run a similar thread. I have a smokie who is very left-field who I think has what it takes to step into the category of DT Premium. I must say I am not 100% locked into this person but a good pre-season and round 1 selection and there is a very good chance.

I will update the OP with all incorrect guesses. Also only 1 guess per post.

Hopefully my smokie has more success than what Blease did for PB, but nonetheless this should be entertaining for a week or so lol.

Your one and only clue is: This player is listed as less than $400,000 in Monty's current fanplanner.

Extra clue: This player is not a ruck

May the guessing begin :)

Incorrect guesses:
Greg Broughton
Ben Howlett
Clancee Pearce
Tom McDonald
Cyril Rioli
Jarryd Blair
Jack Steven
Hamish Hartlett
Sharrod Wellingham
Andrew Gaff
Allen Christensen
Dom Cassissi
Dan Nicholson
Jeremey Howe
Christian Howard
Zac Dawson
Jack Darling
David Myers
Justin Westhoff
Daniel Giansiracusa
Sam Blease
Brent Reilly
Clinton Young
Steven Motlop
Matt de Boer
Mitch Wallis
Jake Melksham
Harley Bennell
Adam Treloar
Jack Ziebell
Tom Liberatore
Brodie Smith
Isaac Smith
Luke Hodge
Luke Ball
Andrew Embley
Jack Watts
Dom Tyson
Dylan Grimes
Luke Breust
Xavier Ellis
Shane Savage
Brad Sheppard
Brad Symes
Tom Couch
Jamie McMillan
Nathan Grima
Kieran Harper
Sam Wright
Brad Crouch
Sam Butler
Mitch Banner
Andy Otten
Luke Parker
Sam Reid
Tom Liberatore
Setanta O'Hailpin
Tom Lynch
Liam Shiels
Reece Conca
Tom Bell
Alex Johnson
Tom Mitchell
Shaun Atley
Dan Hanneberry
Todd Banfield
Claye Beams
Jaimie Elliot
Ryan Bastinac
Bachar Houli
Leigh Adams
Brian Lake
Travis Colyer
Anthony Miles
Brent Prismall
Mitch Golby
Mitch Duncan
Daniel Menzel
Luke Dahlhaus
Kyal Horsely
Michael Walters
Kieren Harper
Jordan Murdoch
Michael Barlow
Aaron Hall
Tory Dickson
Travis Cloke
Heath Shaw
Isaac Smith
David Swallow
Trent McKenzie
Hayden Ballantyne
Stephen Hill
Nathan Van Berlo
Taylor Walker
Kurt Tippett
Karmichael Hunt
Brodie Smith
Lachie Neale
Luke Hodge
Jason Winderlich
Jordan Gysberts
Nic Suban
Bernie Vince
Richard Douglas
Garrick Ibbotson
Nick Smith
Andy Otten
Mitch Morton
Jesse Crichton
Nick Lower

Ricochet

don't bother guessing, its Broughton haha. nah thats not my guess.
by premium you mean...? a lot of ppl have different views on what is a premium for fwds + backs compared to mids

Scrads

Quote from: Ricochet on September 12, 2012, 01:01:24 PM
don't bother guessing, its Broughton haha. nah thats not my guess.
by premium you mean...? a lot of ppl have different views on what is a premium for fwds + backs compared to mids

Haha, not Broughton.

My definition of a Premium:

Back 85+
Mid: 100+
Ruck 90+
Forward 90+

Ricochet


Scrads

Quote from: Ricochet on September 12, 2012, 01:12:49 PM
Broughts wasn't my guess!

Haha, you can have as many guesses as you like man, I just didn't want people going

Pendlebury
Swan
Beams
Ablett
Murphy
.
.
.
.
.
Dawson
Talia

And I just wanted to start the list, and basically ruled him out :P

Matty411

I'm gonna say Ben Howlett from the Dons... Solid average in 2012 and on the way up. With the Dons likely to make the 8 (with Goddard) in 2013, I'm gonna pencil him down for a break out (possibly into the 100+ category).

Now tell me how wrong I am...


Scrads


13Brummy


Ricochet

Cyril Rioli... Just short of a 90 average this year if you take out his sub games

Matty411

If you tell us what position he's in would it be too big a clue? Maybe just rule out a position?

If I could trouble you for a 2nd guess, I'd put forward the name Jarryd Blair from Collingwood Football Club. Very capable of lifting that avg to 90 in 2013 and priced at a decent $375k.

??

Scrads

Quote from: Matty411 on September 12, 2012, 01:39:23 PM
If you tell us what position he's in would it be too big a clue? Maybe just rule out a position?

If I could trouble you for a 2nd guess, I'd put forward the name Jarryd Blair from Collingwood Football Club. Very capable of lifting that avg to 90 in 2013 and priced at a decent $375k.

??

Haha don't want to give too many clues or it will only take a handful of guesses :P but i will say the player is not a ruck.

Blair a good choice, but incorrect. Also you can have as many guesses as you like :P

Matty411

You wouldn't be thinking about Jack Steven (STK) would you? If he's a DPP Forward he's very high on my shortlist... At an Avg of 84 He'll lift it at least above 90 - maybe even above the 100 avg needed for a midfielder...

Close?

tbagrocks


Matty411

Otherwise my last guess for now would be Sharrod Wellingham (C - Collingwood). Dirty maggot of a player but could bring his avg up to 100 as he'll be 25 in 2013 and showed good DT signs this year.