Colin Sylvia 2013 DT/SC

[masedog333]

Before you vote, consider the following points.
- He scores the same amount of points for both DT and SC, averaging 5 more SC points which is about average.That is why this poll is about both DT and SC, he is a great scorer for both comps when at his best.
- He turns 28 in 2 months, so he will be 28 for the whole of the 2013 season. (Swanny was 28 in 2012)
- He averaged approximately 100 SC and DT points if you take out his sub affected games and his games where he got limited game time due to coming back from a long term injury.
- After his bye when he started to become fit after his injury, in 11 games he only dropped below 97 twice , with 7 tons and a 99 and 97. (His other two were 89 and 53).

Gun when fit, will you consider him for 2013?

[quinny88]

Not unless he changes clubs.
Melbourne are a bit of a basket case

[Purple 77]

Not unless he changes clubs.
Melbourne are a bit of a basket case

Agreed. Actually, get him in the last 5 or so games of the year, thats when he decides to pull his finger out and get a contract renewal lol

I think this decision should be based on Melbourne's trading activity i.e. whether they get experienced midfielders. If that is the case, then perhaps he could be a great pick

[LF]

No blacklisted him after last season when he got himself suspended during SC finals last year
Him coupled with restings and players sent off for various surgeries cost me finals since 2 trades can only cover so much.

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Would only consider getting him in the last week to mess with any opponents heads.

[Adamant]

Lock!
Average is severely affected by his games returning from that serious spine injury....so underpriced.

[Ricochet]

definitely considering him this year

[Torress]

the comment about picking him for last 5 games is spot on!! does it every year!

but he did have some big sub affected scores. if the price is right and if i'm feeling extreemly ambitious i might start him.

but he has to have a picture puuuurrrrrfect pre season - no tweaks, no sorness he has to be firing rd 1 for any consideration. to add to that, if melb have a tough draw first 5 or so games i won't even think about it!!!