2013 Player Profile: Marc Murphy

Started by elephants, September 09, 2012, 10:44:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Adamant

Quote from: elephants on September 13, 2012, 10:25:13 PM
Quote from: Adamant on September 13, 2012, 10:19:29 PM
Cotch v Murph for M4...

Murph is 45k cheaper, is priced at a 101 average (after averaging 111 in 2011) and could go back to 110+ with Malthouse in charge.
Cotch finished the year with 10 x 100+ and could really explode next year.

Thoughts?

Ideally I want both but if I was to choose I'd go Murph.

Plenty will disagree with me though - personal preference may come in here ;)
Cheers, I would love both, but that would mean dropping Swanny  :o

elephants

Quote from: Adamant on September 13, 2012, 10:32:15 PM
Quote from: elephants on September 13, 2012, 10:25:13 PM
Quote from: Adamant on September 13, 2012, 10:19:29 PM
Cotch v Murph for M4...

Murph is 45k cheaper, is priced at a 101 average (after averaging 111 in 2011) and could go back to 110+ with Malthouse in charge.
Cotch finished the year with 10 x 100+ and could really explode next year.

Thoughts?

Ideally I want both but if I was to choose I'd go Murph.

Plenty will disagree with me though - personal preference may come in here ;)
Cheers, I would love both, but that would mean dropping Swanny  :o

I just did drop Swanny :o

henry

I've got him in at the moment, with my top 4 mids being Swan, GAJ, Cotchin and Murphy. Taggers are the only issue...

elephants

Quote from: henry on September 14, 2012, 06:03:04 PM
I've got him in at the moment, with my top 4 mids being Swan, GAJ, Cotchin and Murphy. Taggers are the only issue...

Even then Judd is a lock for the first one and Kade, Marc and Gibbs will likely battle it out for the second one (if there is even a second one!?)

Heppell21

In my team at the minute. Still contemplating though.

LaHug

Swan, Ablett, Cotchin, Murphy and ROOKS! Weaken your other lines if you must. LOCK!*

*Disclaimer: There are no actual locks for me in September.

Adamant

Quote from: LaHug on September 25, 2012, 11:49:48 PM
Swan, Ablett, Cotchin, Murphy and ROOKS! Weaken your other lines if you must. LOCK!*

*Disclaimer: There are no actual locks for me in September.
lol. Swap Pendles for Cotch and thats my Mid's.

Toga

thinking about this more, if nathan fyfe is a pure mid i'm actually tempted to get him over murphy - should be about 60K cheaper and i reckon he will tear up next year ::)

Scrads

Will not be going past the big Murph in 2013, locked in for sure.

Shihan7

Currently in my side as M4, good value and can see him finishing a top 6-8 mid :)

essendon2

"Marc Murphy remains as the Blues’ biggest injury concern as he is set to resume training shortly after clean-ups on both his right knee and left shoulder."

hmm Only started training 5 days ago ....  ???

Justin Bieber

Might leave out Murphy and free some dough up for else where.

Mr.Craig

Still 61 days until their first game. I'm not jumping ship until we hit rocks.

tbagrocks

For a lot of players yes i'd agree that it would be risky, but Marc is pure class and far to talented even lacking fitness to stay at around 100 ave

Master Q

Still NAB Cup fellas! Should play a game if fit anyway.