2013 Player Profile: Paul Duffield

Started by Adamant, September 09, 2012, 05:31:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ShaynoB

Wasnt gonna pick him but all this talk about him as made me think!!

For me Goddard and Gibbs pick themselves. Grimes im still not sure about, i know he had a great year last year but he always seems to be 1 hip and shoulder away from a serious injury. I love the idea of Broughton at GC, he wont get touched by taggers with Ablett and Bennell in the team and if let to run free he could rack it up.

For me its between Grimes and Duff!!!

azza707

Quote from: ShaynoB on January 06, 2013, 07:27:04 PM
Wasnt gonna pick him but all this talk about him as made me think!!

For me Goddard and Gibbs pick themselves. Grimes im still not sure about, i know he had a great year last year but he always seems to be 1 hip and shoulder away from a serious injury. I love the idea of Broughton at GC, he wont get touched by taggers with Ablett and Bennell in the team and if let to run free he could rack it up.

For me its between Grimes and Duff!!!

Since when was Broughton ever tagged? it was mainly him tagging the small forwards which hurt his points a little compared to when he played midfield and he could still be playing this role at GC...

timmyparso

Has anyone considered the danyle Pearce factor? He will be competing for possessions in the freo defence

essendon2

Quote from: timmyparso on January 07, 2013, 10:13:12 PM
Has anyone considered the danyle Pearce factor? He will be competing for possessions in the freo defence
+1
This is why I think Heppell > Broughton > Hartlett > Duffield

kilbluff1985

Quote from: essendon2 on January 07, 2013, 10:14:29 PM
Quote from: timmyparso on January 07, 2013, 10:13:12 PM
Has anyone considered the danyle Pearce factor? He will be competing for possessions in the freo defence
+1
This is why I think Heppell > Broughton > Hartlett > Duffield

that's a bit risky mate

essendon2

Quote from: kilbluff1985 on January 08, 2013, 12:30:03 AM
Quote from: essendon2 on January 07, 2013, 10:14:29 PM
Quote from: timmyparso on January 07, 2013, 10:13:12 PM
Has anyone considered the danyle Pearce factor? He will be competing for possessions in the freo defence
+1
This is why I think Heppell > Broughton > Hartlett > Duffield

that's a bit risky mate
no I'm saying Heppell is better than Broughton, who is better than Hartlett, who is better than Duffield

Ricochet

Quote from: timmyparso on January 07, 2013, 10:13:12 PM
Has anyone considered the danyle Pearce factor? He will be competing for possessions in the freo defence
Pearce will probably play on a wing at Freo, with Hill on the other side.

mezzoculo

Quote from: Ricochet on January 08, 2013, 03:06:19 PM
Quote from: timmyparso on January 07, 2013, 10:13:12 PM
Has anyone considered the danyle Pearce factor? He will be competing for possessions in the freo defence
Pearce will probably play on a wing at Freo, with Hill on the other side.
There's been a bit of talk that Pearce doesn't quite have the tank to play out wide on the expanses of Patterson. If that's the case then he may be eased into that position later in the season.

Holz

there are too many good back premiums this year its a shame we only have 6 spots, the 8 mids thing i really dont like it limits the options you can go down back.

Gibbs, Goddard, grimes, duffman, broughton, hartlett i have to cut down to 4.

essendon2

Quote from: Holzman on January 08, 2013, 03:37:44 PM
there are too many good back premiums this year its a shame we only have 6 spots, the 8 mids thing i really dont like it limits the options you can go down back.

Gibbs, Goddard, grimes, duffman, broughton, hartlett i have to cut down to 4.
What about Heppell?

Windigo

I've locked in Grimes, Gibbs & Godd.

There is battle currently between Broughton, Heppell & Duffiled.

Got Duff-Man in there currently, trying to re-kindle the Duff-Love of yester year.  :P

But Heppell if he plays mid may be hard to pass up.  :-\

essendon2

Quote from: Windigo on January 08, 2013, 04:31:35 PM
I've locked in Grimes, Gibbs & Godd.

There is battle currently between Broughton, Heppell & Duffiled.

Got Duff-Man in there currently, trying to re-kindle the Duff-Love of yester year.  :P

But Heppell if he plays mid may be hard to pass up.  :-\
mate can you quickly just give us your average predictions for Broughton, Duffield, Hartlett, Heppell and Grimes!  8) thanks matee

Windigo


Spanner221

playing more then one of Grimes, Hartlett or Broughton just seems to much risk. Once you have Goddard, Gibbs and one of the above 3 the 4th one pretty much has to be Duffield or Heppell . At the moment there seems to be more upside in Heppell.

tbagrocks

Disagree, Broughton is more risky for me and i'll takr Duffman and Hepster