Players that differ in point scoring average in DT and SC

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Next year I want to start doing Super Coach after 4 years of Dream Team, I will assume that similar strategies are used such as Picking Rookies and either upgrading or downgrading them. But what I really want to know is what players score better/worse in Super Coach compared to Dream Team so far the only player that I Know is significantly better in Super Coach is Naitanui.

[MajorLazer]

Believe Shannon Hurn is another. May have improved his DT last season, but he is usually a much better SC player.

[colmullet]

Swan and Boyd are two who are worse off usually in SC

[Ziplock]

basically players who greatly affect a match, but not necessarily with just ridiculous disposal counts. So like, players with huge boots like rich will probably be better SCers, also players who are going to be doing a lot of 1%s, and those that win the hard ball (in DT a mark is 3 points, in SC you get more marks for contested marks etc.)

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

[GoLions]

Players who do better in SC: Pendles, NicNat, Hurn and Suckling usually, Heath Shaw, Priddis, Jelwood(?). There's more, but this is just off the top of my head.

[gossiboy]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

Glass averaged 66 this season, Richards 78 and Rutten 52.

Stay well away from the defenders who take the best forward.

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

Glass averaged 66 this season, Richards 78 and Rutten 52.

Stay well away from the defenders who take the best forward.

Thanks what about key forwards are they any more consistant than key backs?

[GoLions]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

Glass averaged 66 this season, Richards 78 and Rutten 52.

Stay well away from the defenders who take the best forward.

Thanks what about key forwards are they any more consistant than key backs?

Probably a bit better, but still stay away from them. You want the players who have a run in the midfield as well. So like this year good forwards were players like Beams, Dangerfield. Sidebottom, Stevie J, etc.

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

Glass averaged 66 this season, Richards 78 and Rutten 52.

Stay well away from the defenders who take the best forward.

Thanks what about key forwards are they any more consistant than key backs?

Probably a bit better, but still stay away from them. You want the players who have a run in the midfield as well. So like this year good forwards were players like Beams, Dangerfield. Sidebottom, Stevie J, etc.

So it's the same issue consistency.

[gossiboy]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

Glass averaged 66 this season, Richards 78 and Rutten 52.

Stay well away from the defenders who take the best forward.

Thanks what about key forwards are they any more consistant than key backs?

Key forwards much more consistent; Tomahawk averaged 95, Petrie 94.5, Roughy 103.7, JRoo 90 (not bad considering he didn't have a spectacular season despite taking the coleman), Buddy 115, NRoo 95, Tex Walker 100, Tippett 85, Pav 111

Some decent numbers there but, as is the case with DT you'd definitely pick those fwd/mids who are more mids first; Beams avg 122, Danger 115, Sidebum 106, Chappy 100, ROK 103, Bennell 97, Stevie J 97 (not bad considering his first 5 rounds of 58, 68, 56, 69, 65 then his 3 in round 18), Zorko 100.  The only problem being that a few of those guys will probably be listed as mids only next season (beams, sidebum, danger)

Also with the midfielders, you probably already know this but Gary Ablett is the undisputed king of SC, averaged 138 this season and was the top scorer in DT despite missing two games, you must have him in your team round 1.

[GoLions]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

Glass averaged 66 this season, Richards 78 and Rutten 52.

Stay well away from the defenders who take the best forward.

Thanks what about key forwards are they any more consistant than key backs?

Key forwards much more consistent; Tomahawk averaged 95, Petrie 94.5, Roughy 103.7, JRoo 90 (not bad considering he didn't have a spectacular season despite taking the coleman), Buddy 115, NRoo 95, Tex Walker 100, Tippett 85, Pav 111

Some decent numbers there but, as is the case with DT you'd definitely pick those fwd/mids who are more mids first; Beams avg 122, Danger 115, Sidebum 106, Chappy 100, ROK 103, Bennell 97, Stevie J 97 (not bad considering his first 5 rounds of 58, 68, 56, 69, 65 then his 3 in round 18), Zorko 100.  The only problem being that a few of those guys will probably be listed as mids only next season (beams, sidebum, danger)

Also with the midfielders, you probably already know this but Gary Ablett is the undisputed king of SC, averaged 138 this season and was the top scorer in DT despite missing two games, you must have him in your team round 1.

I wouldn't classify Pav and Buddy as key forwards, as they play up the ground a fair bit. Especially Pav. Does Nroo play up the ground a fair bit as well?

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

Glass averaged 66 this season, Richards 78 and Rutten 52.

Stay well away from the defenders who take the best forward.

Thanks what about key forwards are they any more consistant than key backs?

Key forwards much more consistent; Tomahawk averaged 95, Petrie 94.5, Roughy 103.7, JRoo 90 (not bad considering he didn't have a spectacular season despite taking the coleman), Buddy 115, NRoo 95, Tex Walker 100, Tippett 85, Pav 111

Some decent numbers there but, as is the case with DT you'd definitely pick those fwd/mids who are more mids first; Beams avg 122, Danger 115, Sidebum 106, Chappy 100, ROK 103, Bennell 97, Stevie J 97 (not bad considering his first 5 rounds of 58, 68, 56, 69, 65 then his 3 in round 18), Zorko 100.  The only problem being that a few of those guys will probably be listed as mids only next season (beams, sidebum, danger)

Also with the midfielders, you probably already know this but Gary Ablett is the undisputed king of SC, averaged 138 this season and was the top scorer in DT despite missing two games, you must have him in your team round 1.

Thanks you have considerably helped me, don't have any more questions for now.

[gossiboy]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

Glass averaged 66 this season, Richards 78 and Rutten 52.

Stay well away from the defenders who take the best forward.

Thanks what about key forwards are they any more consistant than key backs?

Key forwards much more consistent; Tomahawk averaged 95, Petrie 94.5, Roughy 103.7, JRoo 90 (not bad considering he didn't have a spectacular season despite taking the coleman), Buddy 115, NRoo 95, Tex Walker 100, Tippett 85, Pav 111

Some decent numbers there but, as is the case with DT you'd definitely pick those fwd/mids who are more mids first; Beams avg 122, Danger 115, Sidebum 106, Chappy 100, ROK 103, Bennell 97, Stevie J 97 (not bad considering his first 5 rounds of 58, 68, 56, 69, 65 then his 3 in round 18), Zorko 100.  The only problem being that a few of those guys will probably be listed as mids only next season (beams, sidebum, danger)

Also with the midfielders, you probably already know this but Gary Ablett is the undisputed king of SC, averaged 138 this season and was the top scorer in DT despite missing two games, you must have him in your team round 1.

I wouldn't classify Pav and Buddy as key forwards, as they play up the ground a fair bit. Especially Pav. Does Nroo play up the ground a fair bit as well?

They do, buddy especially, but just thought I'd include them anyway just to give Kellogscrunchynut an idea of their scoring.  I wouldn't really call Roughy a key forward either as he play through the middle a fair bit when he's doing his time in the ruck, same goes for Hale (averaged about 95 this season as a fwd/ruck).

[GoLions]

Do key position players like Glass, Richards and Rutten get scores that are worthy of picking?

Glass averaged 66 this season, Richards 78 and Rutten 52.

Stay well away from the defenders who take the best forward.

Thanks what about key forwards are they any more consistant than key backs?

Key forwards much more consistent; Tomahawk averaged 95, Petrie 94.5, Roughy 103.7, JRoo 90 (not bad considering he didn't have a spectacular season despite taking the coleman), Buddy 115, NRoo 95, Tex Walker 100, Tippett 85, Pav 111

Some decent numbers there but, as is the case with DT you'd definitely pick those fwd/mids who are more mids first; Beams avg 122, Danger 115, Sidebum 106, Chappy 100, ROK 103, Bennell 97, Stevie J 97 (not bad considering his first 5 rounds of 58, 68, 56, 69, 65 then his 3 in round 18), Zorko 100.  The only problem being that a few of those guys will probably be listed as mids only next season (beams, sidebum, danger)

Also with the midfielders, you probably already know this but Gary Ablett is the undisputed king of SC, averaged 138 this season and was the top scorer in DT despite missing two games, you must have him in your team round 1.

I wouldn't classify Pav and Buddy as key forwards, as they play up the ground a fair bit. Especially Pav. Does Nroo play up the ground a fair bit as well?

They do, buddy especially, but just thought I'd include them anyway just to give Kellogscrunchynut an idea of their scoring.  I wouldn't really call Roughy a key forward either as he play through the middle a fair bit when he's doing his time in the ruck, same goes for Hale (averaged about 95 this season as a fwd/ruck).

Yeah, forgot about Roughy. Pretty much most key forwards either kick a bag and score 140, or have an average game and score 50-70.