EURO Trading

[Ricochet]

soo why didn't this get blocked/go to vote?

Eagles Receive: Michael Barlow
Dino's Receive: Nat Pick 1

Barlow is a 24yr old proven 110 player, and we got Fyfe who is a 21 yr old and yes has potential to be a gun but hasn't passed 100 yet.

so

Proven 110 Player
for
N1

compared to

Young 100 player
for
N3 + N14 + N54 + N66 + 2nd year 60 player + Rookie Upgrades

Oh and Spite chucked in Logan, a 58 player who he was going to delist anyway. You can take him out if you like but we have paid so much more than that Barlow trade

[Justin Bieber]

^^ this is true. Hawka strikes again lol

[Holz]

soo why didn't this get blocked/go to vote?

Eagles Receive: Michael Barlow
Dino's Receive: Nat Pick 1

Barlow is a 24yr old proven 110 player, and we got Fyfe who is a 21 yr old and yes has potential to be a gun but hasn't passed 100 yet.

so

Proven 110 Player
for
N1

compared to

Young 100 player
for
N3 + N14 + N54 + N66 + 2nd year 60 player + Rookie Upgrades

Oh and Spite chucked in Logan, a 58 player who he was going to delist anyway. You can take him out if you like but we have paid so much more than that Barlow trade

the difference i see here is you dont give N3 + n14 you gave toumpas and valustin. When i gave pick 1 i let hawka have the option of picking anyone he wanted, If you had of given N3 + n14 instead of wines and vlaustin i would be defending the trade.  Toumpas i dont see ath the 3rd best player in the draft for me he is in the 5-10 range.

I would happily give you guys barlow for fyfe if barlow is a 110 player and fyfe only a 95 :)

[Ricochet]

soo why didn't this get blocked/go to vote?

Eagles Receive: Michael Barlow
Dino's Receive: Nat Pick 1

Barlow is a 24yr old proven 110 player, and we got Fyfe who is a 21 yr old and yes has potential to be a gun but hasn't passed 100 yet.

so

Proven 110 Player
for
N1

compared to

Young 100 player
for
N3 + N14 + N54 + N66 + 2nd year 60 player + Rookie Upgrades

Oh and Spite chucked in Logan, a 58 player who he was going to delist anyway. You can take him out if you like but we have paid so much more than that Barlow trade

the difference i see here is you dont give N3 + n14 you gave toumpas and valustin. When i gave pick 1 i let hawka have the option of picking anyone he wanted, If you had of given N3 + n14 instead of wines and vlaustin i would be defending the trade.  Toumpas i dont see ath the 3rd best player in the draft for me he is in the 5-10 range.

I would happily give you guys barlow for fyfe if barlow is a 110 player and fyfe only a 95 :)

don't forget we are not drafting based on real life, we are drafting based on DT potential... so N1 in the AFL doesn't necessarily equal N1 in this draft. I think Toumpas is a top 5 pick for this, but I'll go with N8

N8 + N14 + N54 + N66 + 2nd year 60 player + Rookie Upgrades

its still a lot more than just N1

[JBs-Hawks]

And fyfe is worth a lot more than Barlow.

[elephants]

And fyfe is worth a lot more than Barlow.

Highly, highly debatable.

[Holz]

And fyfe is worth a lot more than Barlow.

Highly, highly debatable.

lets strike that deal up than :)

[PowerBug]

Did Nails vote? If not can i vote for him? I am opposed to the trade, having the same view as Ziplock.

Just so everyone knows, this Fyfe deal allows Spink and Spite to field a team.

Fair point, no-one likes a side which provides no competition at all. (Serious comment not sarcasm) BUT, had there been little to no trades made to the Greek side from last season to this season, a full side is easily achievable. So it is the way the side is managed really. :-\ And they are going for youth, so as Spite has told me they aren't gonna be competitive next year anyway, it wasn't in the plan.

So i think that point means nothing in the concept of the trade.

[elephants]

And fyfe is worth a lot more than Barlow.

Highly, highly debatable.

lets strike that deal up than :)

We don't have Fyfey yet :P I'd probably rate Fyfey higher but JBs point is irrelevant.

If Fyfe is worth more, we paid more for him than Holz paid for Barlow.

You get me?

[elephants]

Did Nails vote? If not can i vote for him? I am opposed to the trade, having the same view as Ziplock.

Just so everyone knows, this Fyfe deal allows Spink and Spite to field a team.

Fair point, no-one likes a side which provides no competition at all. (Serious comment not sarcasm) BUT, had there been little to no trades made to the Greek side from last season to this season, a full side is easily achievable. So it is the way the side is managed really. :-\ And they are going for youth, so as Spite has told me they aren't gonna be competitive next year anyway, it wasn't in the plan.

So i think that point means nothing in the concept of the trade.

Spite/Spink said it himself, purely going off that.

[Justin Bieber]

I find it funny that Holz is against it, but has Vlastin in his DT this upcoming season lol.

[The F.A.R.K.]

In dt potemtial from this draft it provs goes

Whitfield
Martin
Toumpas
Wines

While orourke and plowman were taken before toumpas because they suited gws needs

Toumpas comes into the afl with a high calibre junior career behind him

An Sanfl premiership
Under 18s sanfl mvps
Numerous metro west medals
Captain of sa side
Ais representative

How is he not in the top 3 players of this draft!!!

[elephants]

I think we are better off just letting the votes sort it our Fark, nothing we can do now...

[Ricochet]

I think we are better off just letting the votes sort it our Fark, nothing we can do now...

yeh but it shouldnt even be going to vote if the Barlow one didn't

[Justin Bieber]

Why did this take a week to go to vote?