British 15's Official Trade period 1 thread

[Colliwobblers]

interesting  :-\

[monstrum]

Got another trade to add to the list...

The mighty Liverpool Lobsters give:

Michael Walters + Nat Pick 53

Staines Steins give:

Claye Beams + Nat Pick 21

Tabs to confirm :)

[Capper]

Got another trade to add to the list...

The mighty Liverpool Lobsters give:

Michael Walters + Nat Pick 53

Staines Steins give:

Claye Beams + Nat Pick 21

Tabs to confirm :)

confirm

[Fletch74]

I thought we were only able to do 5 list movements?

If so, you aren't able to do that trade Monstrum as you did 5 list movements with me ???

[monstrum]

Yeh do draft picks are considered trades in this comp  :-\

I didnt know that, i dont suppose we can change that rule...  ::)

[BB67th]

Big trade reached between the Leeches and Owls

Oxford Owls give: Andrew Carrazzo, Alex Johnson, Jarrad Waite
For
Leeds Leechers give: Greg Broughtan, Josh Tynan and NAT pick 29

Noz to confirm trade

[Noz]

Big trade reached between the Leeches and Owls

Oxford Owls give: Andrew Carrazzo, Alex Johnson, Jarrad Waite
For
Leeds Leechers give: Greg Broughtan, Josh Tynan and NAT pick 29

Noz to confirm trade

Confirmed

Reason: Needed some more defenders with Carrazzo loosing his DPP plus another pick inside the top 30 is handy

[Colliwobblers]

Yeh do draft picks are considered trades in this comp  :-\

I didnt know that, i dont suppose we can change that rule...  ::)

almost 100% sure MTTY has already confirmed earlier in htis thread, draft picks for draft picks trades do NOT count as list movements.

Same as IN Asians.

player - player = YES

player - pick = YES

pick - player = YES

pick - pick = NO

certain of it, could go back and find his post but i can't be bothered :)

[monstrum]

I hope ur right colli!!

Fletch dug this up from the rules i think

It's in the rules...

Trades: You may have up to 5 list changes, meaning that after you have finished drafting in the official draft that you can only add  or take five players/draft picks from your list. However if you get a player and then on trade that same player for another player it will still only count as 1 list change.

[Colliwobblers]

OK so I had to go find his post :)  pretty clear here. but best check with MTTY if any doubts he is the boss :)

1. A list change will occur for both teams if this happens: Player x for Player y

2. A list change will occur for both teams if this happens: Player x for Draft pick

3. A list change will not count if: Draft pick x for Draft pick y


Note: I will put this in the OP.

Therefore (in my non-official opinion, and an opinion that respects your decision) I think that Ringo/Torp trade should be voided (sorry Ringo)

As that trade would take Torp to 6 list changes, and therefore because their trade does not pass, my trade with Torp should pass as it'll take him to 5 list changes as Ringo/Torp's trade should be voided under the rules.

You are correct Nails. Apologies as i had Torp down as Betts not counting as a list movement for him too. (After Betts was on traded but it should still count for Torp).

[monstrum]

Ok after reading that and checking my trades theyre all good!! Thnx colli :)

[Torpedo10]

I trade: Betts, Jenkins, Nat pick 33, Nat pick 36, Nat pick 40.

Ringo trades: Motlop, Nat pick 3, Nat pick 70, Sam Reid(GWS), J. Wilkinson.

Been away for 3 days so confirm the trade. Main interest in Jenkins as a back up ruck.  Other trades and picks to balance,  Leave it to MTTY to decide on legalities.

Bump

[elephants]

Want some quality youth? We have it here!

I'm looking to trade so enquire within :)

[Torpedo10]

This is starting to get silly, trades haven't been checked in ages.  ::)

[Colliwobblers]

This is starting to get silly, trades haven't been checked in ages.  ::)

if you look back to my post which summarized the trades outstanding, the committee all rules on these trades in the affirmative, but obviously ( understandably) none in the committee were willing to post an official passing of the trades in MTTYs absence.

ANd it certainly isn't my place to do so, but I can tell you those that were listed in my post, including both of Ringo's were agreed to by more members of the committee than were left to vote against, meaning they all will pass.

So you can assume very reliably that those trades at  least will pass but obviously it won't be official until MTTY makes it so.

Here is a link to the ones I got answers back in the affirmative from the majority of committee members ( majority including MTTY)

Link:  http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,67577.msg904252.html#msg904252