Scott Thompson??

Started by Madmax75, August 31, 2012, 08:01:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Trade Lake/Giles for Jacobs/H Shaw or Thompson/Giles for Swan/Sandilands

Lake/Giles for Jacobs/H Shaw
Thompson/Giles for Swan/Sandilands
Another double trade metioned in comments: 105 k in the bank

Madmax75

I had traded Lake/Giles out for H Shaw and Jacobs but the continued rumours around a late Crows out have me concerned over Thompson. Not to bothered if Danger is out as my opponent has him too. Thing is its only rumours and the first trade option makes sense. However it comes down to having H Shaw (90)/Jacobs (118)/Thompson(113) or Gibson (94)  (SC Gold 302 combined) or     S Shaw(83) Sandi (94) Swan (131) (SC Gold 308) These are just sc G projections. You would think that H Shaw could go over 100 and Sandi around 120 if not subbed.

Im thinking of going back to option 1 in the poll for two reasons:
1. Its only rumours so far.
2. Gibson is a good back up.
3. Jacobs and H SHaw block two of the few premium differences my opponent has and on averages or projections I should win.

Anyone able to convince me otherwise.
Will cheer for good feedback

NFI Police

Heard from Mark Riccuito on the radio that the crow under a cloud is Tex Walker...fitness test in the morning

Madmax75

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/expert-opinion/big-pav-will-he-or-wont-he/story-fndm7jib-1226462472820

Still nothing official just opinion as far as Danger and Thompson but you are right about Walker. Hmmm big chance the Crows could vest Thompson or Danger. Prob be better if he was a late withdrawal and Gibson was the E for him. Is it worth just putting Sandi and Swan in for Thompson and Giles on what might happen?