What to do with Robbo?

[pinochio]

Who to start out of these two??

im thinking on form treloar is miles in front ye??

[LF]

Same problem I have and Robbo`s form doesn`t warrant him to start.Assistant coach is predicting him as 81 and Treloar as 107.
I`m sticking with Treloar he is playing great.
Besides I thought Robbo was out for the season anyway.

[Turkies]

I've got the same problem but in SC. really tough decision

[McRooster]

Same problem I have and Robbo`s form doesn`t warrant him to start.Assistant coach is predicting him as 81 and Treloar as 107.
I`m sticking with Treloar he is playing great.
Besides I thought Robbo was out for the season anyway.

It appears you haven't voted then LF  ;)

Mitch has a near 90 average v the Saints, Treloar hasn't played North and only has a season average of 81.

Can you afford a nine point gamble in your GF?

[Turkies]

Same problem I have and Robbo`s form doesn`t warrant him to start.Assistant coach is predicting him as 81 and Treloar as 107.
I`m sticking with Treloar he is playing great.
Besides I thought Robbo was out for the season anyway.

It appears you haven't voted then LF  ;)

Mitch has a near 90 average v the Saints, Treloar hasn't played North and only has a season average of 81.

Can you afford a nine point gamble in your GF?

Robbo is coming off 2 sub 50 scores, and has played 2 games in 6 weeks. Showing no form at all and probably a bit underdone.

Treloar is coming off 5 straight 90+ games, and showing he can score great against teams much better (pies 121) and much worse (suns 112) than the kangas.

I've always been a premo's above rookies kinda guy, but on Robbo's form, with his forward tagging role, and named in the fwd line, i might be leaning to treloar now

[Mr.Craig]

I'm sticking Robbo on my mid bench as emergency. Not sure I can warrant giving him a spot ahead of Martin or Zorko.

I could shift Roughy into the ruck and essentially field Robbo over Giles but even that feels like a gamble. :-\

Needless to say I voted for Treloar.

[Turkies]

I'm sticking Robbo on my mid bench as emergency. Not sure I can warrant giving him a spot ahead of Martin or Zorko.

I could shift Roughy into the ruck and essentially field Robbo over Giles but even that feels like a gamble. :-\

Needless to say I voted for Treloar.

Keep in mind Brogan is playing this week

[Mr.Craig]

Keep in mind Brogan is playing this week

That did cross my mind. Then I remembered the last time they played together Giles was BOG and slayed a 124 so I think he's still worthwhile fielding.

[McRooster]

Robbo is coming off 2 sub 50 scores, and has played 2 games in 6 weeks. Showing no form at all and probably a bit underdone.
I've always been a premo's above rookies kinda guy, but on Robbo's form, with his forward tagging role, and named in the fwd line, i might be leaning to treloar now

Are you still leaning that way considering Ratten's departure? Surely the new incumbent/caretaker Coach will relax all previous structures and let mad dog Robbo go at the pill on his own merit.

[Turkies]

Robbo is coming off 2 sub 50 scores, and has played 2 games in 6 weeks. Showing no form at all and probably a bit underdone.
I've always been a premo's above rookies kinda guy, but on Robbo's form, with his forward tagging role, and named in the fwd line, i might be leaning to treloar now

Are you still leaning that way considering Ratten's departure? Surely the new incumbent/caretaker Coach will relax all previous structures and let mad dog Robbo go at the pill on his own merit.

Ratten is coaching out the year... Maybe if there was a new coach, but i think ratten is going to stick to his gameplan

[McRooster]

Robbo is coming off 2 sub 50 scores, and has played 2 games in 6 weeks. Showing no form at all and probably a bit underdone.
I've always been a premo's above rookies kinda guy, but on Robbo's form, with his forward tagging role, and named in the fwd line, i might be leaning to treloar now

Are you still leaning that way considering Ratten's departure? Surely the new incumbent/caretaker Coach will relax all previous structures and let mad dog Robbo go at the pill on his own merit.

Ratten is coaching out the year... Maybe if there was a new coach, but i think ratten is going to stick to his gameplan

Do you think he really GAF?

It'll be like the last week at school - flower it, do whatever you want.

[Fireballz]

Robbo is coming off 2 sub 50 scores, and has played 2 games in 6 weeks. Showing no form at all and probably a bit underdone.
I've always been a premo's above rookies kinda guy, but on Robbo's form, with his forward tagging role, and named in the fwd line, i might be leaning to treloar now

Are you still leaning that way considering Ratten's departure? Surely the new incumbent/caretaker Coach will relax all previous structures and let mad dog Robbo go at the pill on his own merit.

Ratten is coaching out the year... Maybe if there was a new coach, but i think ratten is going to stick to his gameplan

Do you think he really GAF?

It'll be like the last week at school - flower it, do whatever you want.

Ratten might coach for his DT even? I'd play Robbo over Treloar.

[TryAnHit]

robbo or whitecross as last forward. seems close

[KBcokebotl]

have same problem, imo its no contest: treloar on field robbo on bench
form suggests treloar deserves his spot more than robbo. more chance for him to go 120 than robbo

[TheBeatles]

Robbo - carlton will play open game of footy just out for a kick.  Robbo wont have too fwd tag and will roam in the mids and kick a couple of goals - Im Hoping!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ;D