Bench Gibson or Goodes?

Started by no eye deer, August 30, 2012, 10:15:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

no eye deer

So it comes down to this. Need to win my CA$H league!
Mids- GAJ, Pendles, Thomson, Priddis, Murphy, Dusty (Gibson, Baguley)
Fwds- Buddy, Pav, Danger, Sidey, Goodes, Zorko, Stevie J (Couch, Smedts)

Do I play Goodes and risk no cover in the fwds or swing Dusty back down fwd, play Gibson and have Goodes (or someone else?) as cover if Pav or someone else is a late withdrawal?

Also, have one trade left, my opponent has Tex Walker, who I think is the player in his side most at risk of smashing out a winning score this week. Trade Pav or Sidey to Tex or grow some balls and stick with my team?

Cheers in advance for any replies!

quinny88

Do you have any cash to play with?

no eye deer


quinny88

I would look at Dusty > One of..

Mitchell
Sloane
Kerr
NDS
Mundy

Whoever you think will pump out the biggest score

no eye deer

Yeah Dustys not usually good for two in a row, but scared to trade him. Could go big,

quinny88

Quote from: no eye deer on August 30, 2012, 11:12:48 PM
Yeah Dustys not usually good for two in a row, but scared to trade him. Could go big,
Yeah hes just that type haha

no eye deer

Quote from: quinny88 on August 30, 2012, 11:17:03 PM
Quote from: no eye deer on August 30, 2012, 11:12:48 PM
Yeah Dustys not usually good for two in a row, but scared to trade him. Could go big,
Yeah hes just that type haha

That's it man, held him all season, if I trade now he will get 180, so might as well keep and wear his 70 and hope my other boys get me over the line!  ::)

no eye deer

I've been mulling over a few options.

Option 1- Play Gibson on the field. Bench a fwd (Goodes, Dusty, Pav, Sidey?)Pros-good cover on both lines. Cons- Benched gun could go large, Gibson may get vested.

Option 2- Leave Martin in mids. Pros- all guns on the field. Cons- no fwd cover.

Option 3- as per two and use last trade.tobribg in a playing emerg. ( haven't looked in to who's available for say Smedts + $34,800 yet)

Option 4- as per 1 or 2 and sideways trade sidey or Pav to someone who's firing.

Option 5- your ideas. Hit me with 'em! Cheers for ideas!

Adamant


no eye deer

#9
Yeah, I was heading that way, but read another post stating his stats at K Park. Pretty impressive, but his forms been shocking. I could also trade Smedts for Tippett and put him on the bench, or play him and bench Goodes.

Thought I'd add the PODs. In the fwd line are my Pav, Goodes vs his Walker, Wright.

ubeaut

All I can say is don't trade Sidey and make sure u have fwd cover for Pav or anyone else.

I can't advise on Goodes as I'm having the same dilemma whether to play him or not. Wished I'd got Christenson/Walker/anyone who actually got 100/ last week instead of Goodes. Waste of a trade and he scored 72 while Gumbleton got 78 on the bench.

My opponents have him (and last week) and he is a big game player so hard to leave out.

enzedder


no eye deer

#12
Reckon I'll just stick with my side and trade Smedts to Tippett, with Tippett and Gibson warming the pine. C'mon Goodsey, it's your last game before retiring from my Supercoach side. You've been great over the years, let's go out with a bang!  ;D

P.S: Cheers for the replies fellas. Good luck to all this week. Let's bring home the bacon!!!!!!!