Treloar over Pav?

Started by ubeaut, August 23, 2012, 10:31:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ubeaut

Pav is playing injured at FF vs an in form North at Etihad. Treloar is playing on the ball. Surely Bugg or JMac would do the tagging. Surely Greene would cop any tag Saints decided to employ?

What do u guys reckon?

Ziplock

Ward will cop the tag. Probs Jmac tagging tbh.

ubeaut

Thanx again for a reply. But would u play Treloar over Pav?

Adamant

I would feel safer playing Pav.

ubeaut

Quote from: Adamant on August 23, 2012, 10:53:40 PM
I would feel safer playing Pav.
So would I  but that's because he's a proven champ. I can't ignore Pavs' injury cloud (limiting his ability to win ball up the ground) or Norths form (particularly at Etihad) OR Treloars' ability to win the footy whopever he plays against.

ubeaut


m1tch robo

Treloar. He's a gun. Pavleach was pretty average last week and is under an injury cloud

bigballs

yeah you probably have to go Treloar. His last few games have all been over 100 so why will this be any different? As you say, Pav is playing against a quality North outfit and probably won't kick a bag against a good defensive team.

ubeaut


ubeaut

Anyone else? Surely others are worried about Pav? May even be a late out?

n185

Im backing Pav, Treloar has been good but his 100s  came against Port and Gold Coast While Pav has scored over 100 points 8 out of the 9 games... and if he misses treloar will take his spot simple...

ubeaut

Quote from: n185 on August 24, 2012, 05:09:47 PM
Im backing Pav, Treloar has been good but his 100s  came against Port and Gold Coast While Pav has scored over 100 points 8 out of the 9 games... and if he misses treloar will take his spot simple...
Not that simple for me as I have Treloar on my mid bench and can't swap him with anyone else. If Pav misses then I get Gumbletons' score :o