Should I start S.Shaw over M. Johnson?

Started by ubeaut, August 23, 2012, 04:30:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Play S.Shaw over M.Johnson?

Yes Shaw will score well vs Dees Johnson will take a key North tall.
11 (42.3%)
No The ball won't be in Crows backhalf enough
15 (57.7%)

Total Members Voted: 1

ubeaut

This all depends if Heath Shaw is named and / or I trade Lake or not. Please give ur opinion as well. Cheers. :)

KahunaBF

Sam Shaw is either going to be a hero or a villain after the weekend. I am starting him over Lake.

Johnson probably wont be able to sweep across half back.

ubeaut

Looks like a no so far. Please leave a comment. :)

Moona

I have the same predicament.

I think I'll be going Sam Shaw because when the ball is in the middle of the ground, or the crows back half they will probably junk it up a bit to keep control of it before moving it forward.


shuester

shaw scored close to 100 against GWS so the ball will be down in the crows defence more than it was in that game. But you never know with shaw, its either a great score or a horrible one.

JamSainter

With Johnson I know I'll get 80 min.
With Dawson and McPharlin back, certainly helps him but I will be keeping S. Shaw as an emergency. Waay to risky.