AXVs: Official Discussion Thread

Memphistopheles · February 26, 2013, 01:23:56 PM

Our team looks about right although I'd be inclined to start Harper and Embley for us ahead of L Jones and Ellard but that's a matter of personal opinion which I'll discuss with KK later.

Also I imagine there may be some more team changes if Ric does any trades.

Also maybe I'm blind but I just looked and did a Ctrl+F search and I can't find Cox in any of these teams, either in the Ruck or Forward lines.

That has to be an oversight surely - who has Cox?

Toga · February 26, 2013, 01:27:35 PM

Noz (Turkey) has him.

But the Gazelles aren't even listed there!

tbagrocks · February 26, 2013, 01:28:17 PM

How does this all look Coaches? Any changes just say so :) Ok all 16 clubs now

Folders ~~Hawks~~ Ales
Def: Goddard, Mackie, M.Johnson, Reilly Birchall, Pearce, Guerra, Mckenzie
Mid: Swan, McLean, Dal Santo, Foley Kennedy (C), Shuey (VC), Jones, Wells
Ruck: Minson Mumford
For: Zorko, Cloke, Mayne, Ballantyne Breust, Waite, Monfries, Blair
Int: Vince, Bastinac Hodge, Masten

Emg: Merrett, Black, Gilbert Emg: Butler, Broadbent, Edwards

Tigers Lambs
Def: Hartlett, Yarran, Harbrow, Dempster B: Hanley, Houli, Lake, Malceski
Mid: Deledio, Griffen, Greene, Pearce M: Murphy, S.Thompson, O'Keefe, Priddis
Ruck: Sandilands R: Giles
Fwd: D.Martin, Sylvia, Higgins, Christensen F: J Riewoldt, Johnson, Tippett, Petrie
UTI: Ziebell, Knights U: Van Berlo, McVeigh

Emg: Douglas, S.Martin, I.Smith E: Bock, Cooney, West, J.Hill

Eskimos Dongs
Michael Hibberd, Cameron Pedersen (R) Lewis Stevenson, Martin Clarke D - Grimes, Scotland, Chad Cornes, Newman
Scott Pendlebery, Brad Ebert, Ben Howlett, Tendai Mzungu M - Stanton(VC), Montagna, Kelly, Anthony
Paddy Ryder R - Roughead
Cyril Rioli, Luke Dahlhaus, Alan Didak, Liam Jones F - Franklin(C), Pavlich, Bartel, J. Brown
David Ellard, Dan Hannebery U - Kornes, Hayes

EMG: Lachlan Hendersen, Liam Picken, Daniel Currie EMG - C Young, Hale, Tambling

Llamas Strikers
B: Jacobs, L Brown, L Russell, Batchelor B: Matt Suckling, Mitch Golby, Scott D. Thompson, Heath Grundy
M: Danger, Gaff, Wallis, Trengove M: Kieren Jack (C), Steele Sidebottom (VC), Kade Simpson, Sam Gibson
R: Zac Smith R: Sam Jacobs
F: Vickery, Tom Lynch(GC),Cameron , Dev Smith F: Dale Thomas, Mitch Clark, Josh J. Kennedy, Justin Westhoff
U: Matera, Clay Smith U: Tom Scully/Reece Conca

E: Gorringe, Milera, Wingard E: Michael Walters, Ryse Shaw

Bears Crabs
DEF: Beau Waters, Danny Stanley, Paul Duffield, Greg Broughton O'Brien, Morris, Carlisle, Tapscott
MID: Matthew Boyd, Joel Selwood, Shane Tuck, Nathan Fyfe Steven (c), Prestia, Mzungu, Treloar
RUC: Ben McEvoy Nic Nat
FWD: Mitch Robinson, Nick Riewoldt, Brent Harvey, Andrew Walker Hawkins, Darling, Dawes, Jetta
UTI: Sam Mitchell, Daniel Cross Adams, O'Meara

EMG: E:

Vipers Crocodiles
DEF: Courtenay Dempsey / Troy Chaplin/ Christian Howard / David Myers DEF Gibbs, H.Taylor, D.Grimes, Davis
MID: Dayne Beams (C) / Scott Thompson (VC) / Chris Judd / Rhys Palmer MID Cotchin (C), Bennell, Rich, Coniglio
RUCK: Hamish McIntosh RUCK Bellchambers
FWD: Mitch Robinson / Steve Johnson / Robin Nahas / Billie Smedts FWD Lecras, Lew.Jetta, Hurley, Betts
UTILITY: Luke Parker / Stephen Hill UTIL Caddy, Liberatore

EMERGENCY: Nick Suban / Matthew Luenberger / Paul Puopolo / Sam Blease E:

Elephants Head Hunters
D: Jack Watts, Alex Rance, Brodie Smith, Daniel Nicholson D: T Bugg. G Ibbotson. D Heppell. S Burgoyne
M: Jack Redden (C), Michael Barlow (VC), Scott Selwood, Travis Boak, M: A Swallow. C Ward. D Swallow. D Armatige
R: Todd Goldstein R: Z Clarke
F: Taylor Walker, Alex Fasolo, Stewart Crameri, Johnathon Patton F: J Bolton. L Thomas. J Garlett. T Rockliff
U: Dylan Shiel, Liam Shiels U: Matt DeBoer Andrew Carrazzo

E: E: Colin Garland Rhys Stanley David McKay

Dolphins Gazelles
DEF: J.Adcock, C.Enright, J.Brennan, N.Vlastuin Heath Shaw, Nathan Grima, Sam Fisher, Shaun Atley
MID: G.Ablett, R.Sloane, D.Zaharakis , M.Rosa Jobe Watson, David Mundy, Brad Sewell, Luke Ball
RUC: M.Kreuzer Ivan Maric
FWD: J.Porplyzia, J.Lewis, T.Varcoe, B.McGlynn Paul Chapman, Dean Cox, Leigh Adams, Adam Goodes
UTI: J.Corey, S.Savage Ben Cunnington, Mitchell Duncan

EMG: E: Danial Kerr, Shaun Atley, Aaron Siposs

Memphistopheles · February 26, 2013, 01:55:14 PM

Sorry tbag, you're doing a great job but Boyd is now listed for two teams - Bears and Gazelles. And while you're at it Atley is listed both in defence and on the bench for the Gazelles as well.

tbagrocks · February 26, 2013, 02:02:15 PM

This is what happens when people don't update their teams either in prospective lineups or more improtantly their own team threads ::)

So which teams do they actually play for?

Nails · February 26, 2013, 02:04:54 PM

D - Grimes, Scotland, Tambling, Newman
M - Stanton(VC), Montagna, Kelly, Anthony
R - Roughead
F - Franklin(C), Pavlich, Bartel, J. Brown
Int - Kornes, Hayes

Emergency: Young, Hale, McPharlin

There you go tbag. Tambling going to kill the NAB, so he's in. I think Chad is injured, so he's out. McPharlin to bench cover.

Not sure where you got Schulz as emerg, idk.

tbagrocks · February 26, 2013, 02:13:44 PM

Quote from: Nails on February 21, 2013, 12:17:24 AM
D - Grimes, Scotland, Chad Cornes, Newman
M - Stanton(VC), Montagna, Kelly, Anthony
R - Roughead
F - Franklin(C), Pavlich, Bartel, J. Brown
Int - Kornes, Hayes

Emergencies are:

Mid- Clinton Young (109.5) who looks like (based on NAB cup) he'll kill it at the pies. Hope I named him in my Cap team (not sure if I did)

Fwd/Ruck - I'll probably use the 101 average Hale in this position, however if I feel strongly about Roughead being likely to play I'll upgrade to a Fwd only emerg in the 113 average Schulz

Def - As I'm guessing Newman will average more than McPharlin with his midfield role and now that CCornes is a defender, the 94 ave McPharlin will be our Def emergency.

???

Nails · February 26, 2013, 02:15:08 PM

If you read it through properly

It's 1x mid, 1xf/r and 1x def

It's Hale OR Schulz, never both at the same time.

Memphistopheles · February 26, 2013, 02:17:11 PM

Quote from: Nails on February 26, 2013, 02:04:54 PM
D - Grimes, Scotland, Tambling, Newman
M - Stanton(VC), Montagna, Kelly, Anthony
R - Roughead
F - Franklin(C), Pavlich, Bartel, J. Brown
Int - Kornes, Hayes

Emergency: Young, Hale, McPharlin

There you go tbag. Tambling going to kill the NAB, so he's in. I think Chad is injured, so he's out. McPharlin to bench cover.

Not sure where you got Schulz as emerg, idk.

Really Nails? You're going to start Spud Tambling over a potential 100 avg defender in McPharlin who ranked first in total marks and marks per game in 2012?

I might have to reconsider who's my favourite for the Asian XVs title this season if you're going to make spuddy decisions like these.

I suppose though you will come to your senses as Scotland is suspended for the first two games so McPharlin will play rounds 1 & 2 and you'll realise he's 100 times better than Tambling.

Also tbag I believe Boyd is at the Bears now but I'm not sure who moved to the Gazelles in the trade.

nostradamus · February 26, 2013, 02:20:30 PM

The Crabs have traded out Mzungu, current team is in our team thread though

The team will be prety much as you've suggested but there will be a few changes....Macaffer will definately be in again

But l'll post our team a bit later in the week mate

*you're doing a great job Tbag....well done ;)

Nails · February 26, 2013, 02:29:43 PM

Quote from: Memphistopheles on February 26, 2013, 02:17:11 PM
Quote from: Nails on February 26, 2013, 02:04:54 PM
D - Grimes, Scotland, Tambling, Newman
M - Stanton(VC), Montagna, Kelly, Anthony
R - Roughead
F - Franklin(C), Pavlich, Bartel, J. Brown
Int - Kornes, Hayes

Emergency: Young, Hale, McPharlin

There you go tbag. Tambling going to kill the NAB, so he's in. I think Chad is injured, so he's out. McPharlin to bench cover.

Not sure where you got Schulz as emerg, idk.

Really Nails? You're going to start Spud Tambling over a potential 100 avg defender in McPharlin who ranked first in total marks and marks per game in 2012?

I might have to reconsider who's my favourite for the Asian XVs title this season if you're going to make spuddy decisions like these.

I suppose though you will come to your senses as Scotland is suspended for the first two games so McPharlin will play rounds 1 & 2 and you'll realise he's 100 times better than Tambling.

Also tbag I believe Boyd is at the Bears now but I'm not sure who moved to the Gazelles in the trade.

I was thinking that was team list for AXVs CAp round 2, but now I realise probably not

and McPharlin is behind Newman and Chad Cornes anyway.

Tambling should/will break out this season as shown already in pre-season.

http://www.afc.com.au/news/2013-02-23/crows-sink-dockers-in-a-thriller

Tambling DESTROYED in their trial game vs. Dockers

He also put up some decent/nice numbers in the NAB cup fixtures so far.

tbagrocks · February 26, 2013, 02:30:56 PM

Thanks, this isn't for the Cap teams, this is for the full season, trying to get a good starting guide of everyone to get some odds going :D

Nails · February 26, 2013, 02:34:48 PM

My lineup is in prospective lineups.

But yeah, it's Hale OR Schulz

When I think Roughead is 100% to play or has Friday night teams so I can be certain he won't be a late withdrawal then we use Schulz

Hale is good as we can cover all 4 spots with 3 players and don't need the 50% penalty.

tbagrocks · February 26, 2013, 02:37:37 PM

Here's what i'm going to do, my post is number three in the Prospective-linups thread, I will post all the lineups there, this will be your yearly prospected line up, so I can change it there whenever and everyone can see the teams easliy

Nails · February 26, 2013, 02:48:45 PM

Oh and McPharlin starts behind Chad Cornes provided everyone is 100% fit anyway meph

McPharlin only averaged 94 too Meph... so not THAT great. But yeah, who knows, Tambling could destroy.