Swan or Watson guys and girls

[Marcos83]

Need to upgrade Gibson to a super premium, cash not an issue and have a week off this week. Perfect for swan to come in at the right time.

Thoughts everyone.

[quinny88]

I dont think you could go wrong either way. Maybe swan? Only just.. and i have no reason why lol

[colmullet]

Watson for mine, less people to steal points off him

[LF]

I have both but if I were to pick one over the other i'd pick Watson.

[Jroo]

Swan, he should come back refreshed and he will be disapointed about missing 2 weeks and will come out and smash two scores of 150+

[kilbluff1985]

Watson for mine, less people to steal points off him

+1 brownlow fav expect big efforts from him in the next few weeks

don't know how Swan will go after the club suspended him he is the type of guy to have a quiet game just to teach them a lesson

[Spinking]

Historically Swanny comes back pretty well from a break. Watts may be tiring after a long season. I'd back in Swanny.

[Justin Bieber]

Maybe wait on Swan next week, since he is not playing and you don't know what could happen in a week ??

[Turkies]

Swan.
Fresh legs so should be running hard and getting lots of it. Historically does fairly well against West Coast. Scores of 117 and 86 (when he was playing injured last year), but before that had 163, 149 and 146. Also smashes it against Bombers, scoring 180 earlier in the year, as well as 176 and 106 (think that was also when he started carrying some niggles early in the year).

Watson may be getting tired at  the end of a long year, and has a tough last 2 rounds. against Richmond he scores OK, 105 this year, 124 in 2010. And the Pies who he had 93 earlier on in the year, and 119, 90, 119 & 80 in the previous 2 years. Not great scores.

If you wanted a player for this week, I'd go Watson, but if you've got the week off and going to trade next week anyway, go with Swanny

[no eye deer]

I'm making the exact same trade next week after the week off this week. I'm also leaning towards Swan, reckon he'll smash it coming back. Watson is tempting, but hes carrying a huge weight on his shoulders, with his team falling apart around him. Can he keep it up? Probably! Will decide about two minutes before lockout next week ( if no more spanners are thrown into the works between now and then  ::))

[Bedlam]

Swan, but wait il next week to pull it. His price int gonna change and you never know what's gonna happen between now and then

[Jroo]

Swan, but wait il next week to pull it. His price int gonna change and you never know what's gonna happen between now and then

+1 wait a week if you want Swan

[T Dog]

Maybe wait on Swan next week, since he is not playing and you don't know what could happen in a week ??

+1

[bensl]

Swan, but wait il next week to pull it. His price int gonna change and you never know what's gonna happen between now and then

agreed