Who to bench - Rockliff or Gibson?

Started by wixy, August 15, 2012, 07:08:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who to bench - Rockliff or Gibson?

Rockliff
10 (55.6%)
Gibson
8 (44.4%)

Total Members Voted: 1

wixy

Who would you bench out of Rockliff and Gibson for this round?

Rockliff has terrible recent form, but is playing Adelaide at home which could be good.

Gibson has great recent form, but is playing Collingwood which could be bad.

Adamant

Not really a fan of playing rooks over premo's (unless zorko) as they have the potential to smash out huge scores... Rocky for me.

masedog333

Quote from: Adamant on August 15, 2012, 07:28:49 PM
Not really a fan of playing rooks over premo's (unless zorko) as they have the potential to smash out huge scores... Rocky for me.
+1 go with rocky mate

quinny88

Quote from: wixy on August 15, 2012, 07:08:09 PM
Who would you bench out of Rockliff and Gibson for this round?

Rockliff has terrible recent form, but is playing Adelaide at home which could be good.

Gibson has great recent form, but is playing Collingwood which could be bad.


Why would playing Adelaide be a good thing? They are a top side.

In saying that I would still go with Rocky

My Chumps

Can't just jump off a proven preformer like Rocky after a few rocky weeks (pun intended).

Stick with him.

kilbluff1985

play Rockliff, Gibbo might/could/should struggle against Pies midfield

Spite

Gibson against Pies? Go with Rocky man :)