AXVs: Official Drafts

[Nails]

If this spud didn't get drafted... why is he going to be such a gun?

idk who this sam rand is.

It's not about what the clubs think about them, it's all about what they do on the field!, if a player has 30 kicks and they all go to the opp he still gets 120 points ;)

It's not about how good the player is, you won't see Daniel Talia in my squad, but is he in the most improtant to the team? It's all about guys that get the footy!

So a player that's going to get zero games at his AFL club is worth about zero...

Picking up that spud w/ rookie pick 1 might do Lez a favour.

[Justin Bieber]

How's the vote going?

[Colliwobblers]

How's the vote going?

4 coaches left to vote and it is undecided. will need every vote.

JROO8
Monstrom
Koop

Me.

I will vote on the side of the option that leads after those last 3 votes as always.

Next season is already decided the outcome is a clear majority, but this season is undecided.

[KoopKicka]

How's the vote going?

4 coaches left to vote and it is undecided. will need every vote.

JROO8
Monstrom
Koop

Me.

I will vote on the side of the option that leads after those last 3 votes as always.

Next season is already decided the outcome is a clear majority, but this season is undecided.

I Pmed you last night? ;)

[Colliwobblers]

so you did my bad.

JROO8
Monstrom


Me and that is all....

[nostradamus]

so you did my bad.

JROO8
Monstrom


Me and that is all....

it'll be interesting to see which way it goes

......but from the posts in previous pages it seems like both JROO8 and Monstrum will go with the status quo this season

[Colliwobblers]

well JROO8 has a bunch of picks in the first round of the rookie draft, so that would seem not to suit him.

But we will see, it seems exactly HALF of us will NOT be happy whichever way it goes, which is why it's better to make it everyones decision not just mine.

the rule will be changed for future seasons that much is certain already. Which tends to make me think that the changed rule is/was the right one.

But everyone has/had the choice to change it now or not until next season, the final two votes, plus if required mine will sort it out anyway.

I have sent a reminder PM to the two remaining coaches, as soon as they vote and me if required i will post results and restart draft.

Unless there is a deadlock which is possible in which case I will announce an avenue for resolution at that time all voted are in.

[Justin Bieber]

Jroo wanta to skip so he votes for it... People needed to know that I would be strongly against this whether i had rookie pick one or not. Horrible rule and people who knew about it should of said something

[Justin Bieber]

Rookie pick 1 for Nat 33. We lose* big time but would prefer to do this deal

Would even out for both parties?? Its a fair solution... make a vote on that maybe?

[Colliwobblers]

If option A is voted in but my vote would tie the voting, it may be possible and best to have a compromise rule for this season only.

My thoughts would be putting all the national draft passing compensation picks in BEHIND a certain number of existing rookie/PSD picks.

for example - round 1, or first 10.

the hard part in doing this and why i didn't add it as an option, is where is fair to place the cut off and add in the compensation picks.

if there can be a general consensus formed as to where this cut off point should be if we do have a deadlock, feel free to discuss and it may speed things up if we end up in a deadlock and need an alternate solution.

The other option which will almost certainly result in a B vote is I will have the 3 other XVS administrators vote on the option which will give a majority result and decide the matter.

(if any of the other XVS admin are associated with an AXVs team I will find another trusted person to vote in their place).

[Colliwobblers]

just monstrom to vote and me. I will vote with my conscience on this one not with the majority, well possibly with the majority depending on how Monstrom votes.

[Justin Bieber]

This vote is either vote for whatlez or tbag...

If option A goes up then I believe no one else who passes should go to the top of rookie picks. In saying this, if that is the case then i believe some people change their votes.

Still haven't gotten an answer on this yet? My rookie pick one can potentially be rookie pick 15? Which is stupid and ruins the game.

[Justin Bieber]

This vote is either vote for whatlez or tbag...

If option A goes up then I believe no one else who passes should go to the top of rookie picks. In saying this, if that is the case then i believe some people change their votes.

Still haven't gotten an answer on this yet? My rookie pick one can potentially be rookie pick 15? Which is stupid and ruins the game.

[tbagrocks]

That's where we differ as I see the rule as totally fair and it evens it up, Rookie 1,17 is a big difference from 16,32 (Nails), the Draft evened it up and with your earlier Rookie picks makes it fair.

So this rule or loophole really is a leveler, it means you don't just get pick one which is a little unfair, so stratagy comes into it! It was a great rule for the start of the league, you just don't see it as you thought your pick one was safe ;)

[picker_man]

This vote is either vote for whatlez or tbag...

If option A goes up then I believe no one else who passes should go to the top of rookie picks. In saying this, if that is the case then i believe some people change their votes.

Still haven't gotten an answer on this yet? My rookie pick one can potentially be rookie pick 15? Which is stupid and ruins the game.

Nah i didnt let my vote come to that ;). Even though leaving it as is would benifit my team more as i will be getting better players with my later nat picks the more people who skip, it is completely unfair to the teams with early rookie picks imo so voted that way