Last Defender

Started by Swannies87, August 13, 2012, 01:04:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who will be the best choice?

Matt Suckling
Paul Duffield
Dyson Heppel
Corey Enright
Jed Adcock

Swannies87

Looking to get rid of Broughton for one of the above choices (only want to use a single trade)

Backline stands - Lids, Scotland, Goddard, Carrots, H.Shaw, Birchall, Smedts (S.Shaw, Broughton)

Only have 364,000 to spend and not sure who to choose  ???

LaHug

Wouldn't dream of touching Suckling or Enright. Adcock *could* be ok and Duffield is a Docker which means Lyon could destroy him at any moment...

The leaves Heppell and is who I would go with.

Swannies87

Cheers, I'm tossing up between Heppel and Suckling  :-\

Suckling can go bang and produce a winning score or just stink it up, where as Heppel is much more consistent. Tough choice....

LaHug

Well, if you're an underdog and must win this week, Suckling against the Suns (assuming he holds his spot in the team) must be tempting. However, if you want three weeks of consistently good scoring, Heppell should be your man.
Good luck either way :)

kilbluff1985

yeah Suckling out of those only because they are playing GC this week think him being sub was Carko's way of resting him for finals well i hope

Bak2Form


powersuperkents

Quote from: Swannies87 on August 13, 2012, 02:19:27 PM
Cheers, I'm tossing up between Heppel and Suckling  :-\

Suckling can go bang and produce a winning score or just stink it up, where as Heppel is much more consistent. Tough choice....
Its finals you'd rather be safe but Id take the risk and hope it pays off, depends if you are in a easy winning position (Heppell if your in top 2) or need a boost (bottom 6 go Suckling)

Swannies87

Think i'm gonna take a punt on suckers and hope he can come up with a 3 round average of 85+  :-X

tbagrocks

Quote from: Swannies87 on August 13, 2012, 03:16:58 PM
Think i'm gonna take a punt on suckers and hope he can come up with a 3 round average of 85+  :-X
has three scores under 60 in five weeks, consider this before trading

Zombie2.5

None of those options look too exciting... especially with Suckers' recent form, but comparing them all, I'd still have to say Suckling

He can produce big scores and junk it up big, he can have downers, but I think he's better than the others anyways

Adamant

Heppell for safety, Suckers for an X Factor in finals.