Gibson

[Lozza]

After his past couple of scores im sick of seeing him on my bench with rockliff spudding it up on the field. Thinking of trading out one of them for fyfe. Who should I trade out and is fyfe my best option or am i better off getting a better mid premo. (also thinking of ousting franklin if he isnt named this week)

$105k in bank 2 trades

Mid: Ablett, Boyd, Thompson, Mitchell, Rockliff, Gibson, Swan, Couch

Fwd: Beams, Sidebottom, Robinson, Chapman, Zorko, Martin, Franklin, Cameron, Murdoch

[kilbluff1985]

um pretty sure Fyfe rolled his ankle hence did not play

[Lozza]

yeah but you wouldnt think its a long term injury?

[kilbluff1985]

don't matter to get an injury prone player at this stage is crazy

[LaHug]

Rockliff to Watson, Cotchin or Pendles in that order. Obviously depends on how much cash you want left over for your last upgrade in finals but screw getting Fyfe when these guys are on the table.

[Fireballz]

Rockliff to Watson, Cotchin or Pendles in that order. Obviously depends on how much cash you want left over for your last upgrade in finals but screw getting Fyfe when these guys are on the table.

Wise words LH, looks like we're in agreeance again!

[Lozza]

$5k short off watson, and probably wouldnt prefer pendelbury since my main opponent has him

[Fireballz]

$5k short off watson, and probably wouldnt prefer pendelbury since my main opponent has him

That just means it'll hurt more when he smashes out a 140 ;)
I never worry about who my opponent has. Concentrate instead on how you can make your team score as high as possible. Remember, points of difference can work both ways!

[Lozza]

so pendelbury over cotchin, looking at cotchins scores and hes tonned up the last 7 games, only thing is he plays port in round 23 and only scored 63 against them last time, does anyone know why? was he tagged?

[tbagrocks]

Gibbo's played last three weeks for me (three tons 8)) with flowerpot Ziebell out, well when Jack comes back I might just have to keep Gibbo playing?

[Fireballz]

Looking at his stats he's only had one good game against Port. I prefer Pendles anyway and he's scored well recently against his remaining opponents. But Cotchin is in ripping form so toss a coin? If it was my decision I'd go Pendles.

[LaHug]

$112k in bank 2 trades

$5k short off watson, and probably wouldnt prefer pendelbury since my main opponent has him

Pardon my maths but...
Rockliff = $400,300
Watson = $510,800

Watson - Rockliff = $110,500

$112,000 - $110,500 = $1,500

How are you $5k short??

so pendelbury over cotchin, looking at cotchins scores and hes tonned up the last 7 games, only thing is he plays port in round 23 and only scored 63 against them last time, does anyone know why? was he tagged?

Trent Cotchin in the form of his life! 112 against Freo, 143 against Essendon, 63 against Port was just a rare bad game. I don't expect a repeat at all!

[LF]

Cotchin's Stats for this year copy and pasted from another post I answered on Friday.
this year.Had a excellent record at the MCG this year.

highest score 143 v Essendon at MCG
Lowest score 63 v Port
Lowest score at the MCG 88 highest 143
average for games at the MCG this year 110.3 played 10 games so far this year
 
Last games for Richmond this year
Bulldogs at MCG
Freo at Pattison
Bombers at MCG
Port at MCG

Previous scores v 4 final opponents
Bulldogs haven`t play them yet but score 79 against them last year in round 8
Freo 112
Bombers 143
Port 63

[Fireballz]

Cotchin's Stats for this year copy and pasted from another post I answered on Friday.
this year.Had a excellent record at the MCG this year.

highest score 143 v Essendon at MCG
Lowest score 63 v Port
Lowest score at the MCG 88 highest 143
average for games at the MCG this year 110.3 played 10 games so far this year

Last games for Richmond this year
Bulldogs at MCG
Freo at Pattison
Bombers at MCG
Port at MCG

Previous scores v 4 final opponents
Bulldogs haven`t play them yet but score 79 against them last year in round 8
Freo 112
Bombers 143
Port 63

So he almost doubled his last score against the doggies? Interesting...

[Lozza]

$112k in bank 2 trades

$5k short off watson, and probably wouldnt prefer pendelbury since my main opponent has him

Pardon my maths but...
Rockliff = $400,300
Watson = $510,800

Watson - Rockliff = $110,500

$112,000 - $110,500 = $1,500

How are you $5k short??

Sorry my mistake, only got $104,900

Cotchin's Stats for this year copy and pasted from another post I answered on Friday.
this year.Had a excellent record at the MCG this year.

highest score 143 v Essendon at MCG
Lowest score 63 v Port
Lowest score at the MCG 88 highest 143
average for games at the MCG this year 110.3 played 10 games so far this year

Last games for Richmond this year
Bulldogs at MCG
Freo at Pattison
Bombers at MCG
Port at MCG

Previous scores v 4 final opponents
Bulldogs haven`t play them yet but score 79 against them last year in round 8
Freo 112
Bombers 143
Port 63

Yeah I must admit he's hard to resist at the moment