Need to stay in the top 100, Clarke v S.Shaw

[Holz]

I normally can easily make bench choices and Im already playing trealor over gibson (gibson will have a slow game)

Have Been struggling with Marty Clakre v Sam Shaw. Shaw was horrible for 3 quarters last week than had a good last 1/4. Clarke is on the edge of the 22, was sub 2 weeks ago than came on around half time for a 60.

The collingwood bench is Clarke, Dids, Seedsman: if clarke can avoid the vest he coudl post a big score.

No clue what to do.

[Windigo]

If we knew that Clarke wasn't gunna be sub, I'd definitely back him in.

I'd still go Marty though....Shaw can put in a stinker or two.  :-\

[Jigsaw]

Man, that is a tough call.

I'd go Clarke, only just but. I agree with Windigo, Shaw can have a shocker here and there.

Even when Clarke started as the sub though, he faired ok DT wise. Hopefully he avoids the vest this time for your sake.

[nostradamus]

l would go Shaw, he's pretty steady and won't get the vest. Whereas Marty is a chance to get the vest, on top of that he plays his best games when allowed to run free.....l just cant see that happening against Sydney

[Artax]

Back in Shaw. Clarke will probably go to Jack this week I think

[Justin Bieber]

I'm sure you will make the right choice.

[Holz]

I'm sure you will make the right choice.

thanks lez, im pretty sure I will make the wrong choice. But im taking a risk and going clarke. Shaw the smart option and my gut says Shaw but im going Clarke for some reason.

the advice while very good, hasnt helped the choice at all with people bringing up good points on each side. Just have to go with the collingwood guy for DT i think.

[Adamant]

Marty

[Justin Bieber]

The funny thing is, that I was meant to misspell Sure to Shaw to give a hint.... and I failed lol.

[Flame]

Go Clarke just!!

[Spinking]

Most of the best quality coaches in here are saying Clarke, which is probably good advice, but I've got a good feeling about Shaw this week. Not a big fan of Marty's so could be biased but would back Shaw to start getting back to good form.

[Bak2Form]

shaw  :)

[Holz]

Most of the best quality coaches in here are saying Clarke, which is probably good advice, but I've got a good feeling about Shaw this week. Not a big fan of Marty's so could be biased but would back Shaw to start getting back to good form.

dam spinking had my mind up on clarke (especially with lez going for shaw) but now its more difficult. Im sure no matter the choice i will make the wrong one.

[Justin Bieber]

Most of the best quality coaches in here are saying Clarke, which is probably good advice, but I've got a good feeling about Shaw this week. Not a big fan of Marty's so could be biased but would back Shaw to start getting back to good form.

dam spinking had my mind up on clarke (especially with lez going for shaw) but now its more difficult. Im sure no matter the choice i will make the wrong one.

That is rude, but we are versing each other which I only just remembered...

[DT Gun]

Ya cant go clarke based on the fact he might be sub and shaw wont

If you pick clarke and he isnt the sub, and scores more than shaw it is no more than a low percentage fluke