Sam Shaw vs Lake? Who to start? Will Cheer!

[Jroo]

Still can't split either of Sam Shaw and Lake? Who should I start? If you comment you get a cheer!

[devize]

I'm deciding whether to start Lake or Spurr this week too. Giving one more chance to Lake, think he should do an okay job against Richmond's forwards.

[bensl]

i have this same decision.  i think i will go with lake simply because he is more proven. i would not be surprised to see shaw outscore him though.  not much help eh!

[Blues Blues Blues]

I started the same thread JROO, and am leaning to Lake for the reason devize has said. 1 more chance for the big lug, and should hopefully rack up some marks against the Tiges.

[dswallow24]

I reckon Shaw 80 to Lakes 70

[almax]

I traded Lake out for bubble boy Browne, pocketed ~$300k and put S.Shaw on the field, now i have 2 trades left to use that $300k

[tor01doc]

I'm Shaw Lake will score more.

[Elite87]

Im in the same boat.Cant decide between the two. But Im confident of winning so Im gona go Shaw. Lake is more likely to get a big score, but I wouldnt be surprised if Shaw pulls of a score in the 80-90 range, and Lake gets a 45 or something.. though he should do well against the Tiges. Hard decision..im going the young gun over the old slug

[Swallow12]

Shaw, cant go past form

[enzedder]

Lake. I am and putting Shaw and Spurr on the pine.
Not racking my brain over it. Probably not much in it so trust in Lake who is more likely to score a 100+ based on previous scores.
Lock it and hope for the best.

[ubeaut]

Yeah I'm sticking with Lake. Last time I benched him (round 2) he scored 100+. Hopefully Roughead will take JROO at times and free up Lake a bit. Even if not Lake is a much more experienced head than JROO, who's not in the best form.

[beafchief]

I can see Lake racking up the points on Sunday

[Spinking]

I'd guess Lake will go to JRoo and he seems to struggle playing tight on a gun forward. If he gets going he will definitely score more than Shaw, but I don't think it's going to happen.

Shaw for me.

[ubeaut]

I'd guess Lake will go to JRoo and he seems to struggle playing tight on a gun forward. If he gets going he will definitely score more than Shaw, but I don't think it's going to happen.

Shaw for me.

He played awesome tight on Cloke. Oh wait, u said a GUN forward...... ;D

[fever]

given richmonds inability to kick to advantage i'm backing lake in for lots of marks from opposition long kicks.