Last 2 trades, out with a BANG! Trade Porps or Chappy?

Blues Blues Blues · August 10, 2012, 03:41:51 PM

Down to 2 trades but going to use them with my horrendous list of outs.

Trade 1: Am going to trade Buddy > Beams - locked and loaded
Trade 2: Porps/Chappy > Fyfe

Which one should I trade?
- Chappy: better scoring potential, but how bad is his calf (or hamstring??!)
- Porps: return next week, and was in great form before injury. Plus Crows have 'Dream' run home

Current Team (with 2 trades and $59k)
BACKS: Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, H Shaw, Carrazzo, Enright, Lake (S Shaw, Bell)
MIDS: Ablett, Watson, Jelwood, Pendles, Thompson, Gibson (Swan, Couch)
RUCKS: Maric, Mummy (Orren, Campbell)
FWDS: Danger, Sidey, Goodes, Martin, Zorko, Darling, CHAPMAN (PORPS, BUDDY)

Cheers

The Bomber · August 10, 2012, 04:06:42 PM

Flip of a coin. Porps might not be back next week given their Dream Run and that he does have iffy shoulders. They want him 100% for the finals...

Same deal with Chappy. Remember Mitch Robbo a few weeks back was a late out and ended up missing 3 weeks...

I'd trade whoever gets you the better player...

Nieso FC · August 10, 2012, 04:27:29 PM

Porps was never intended to be a permanent fixture in your team was he?

Chappy always was so I would trade Porps at least that is an upgrade rather than a sideways trade.

devize · August 10, 2012, 05:19:37 PM

Chappy also has DPP which could be handy should Couch get another game and you get more injuries.

Blues Blues Blues · August 10, 2012, 05:22:11 PM

Cheers guys, Porps it is.

Quote from: devize on August 10, 2012, 05:19:37 PM
Chappy also has DPP which could be handy should Couch get another game and you get more injuries.

Good point devize

Quote from: Nieso FC on August 10, 2012, 04:27:29 PM
Porps was never intended to be a permanent fixture in your team was he?

Chappy always was so I would trade Porps at least that is an upgrade rather than a sideways trade.

No never a permanent fixture, but was hoping he would be a F8 or F9. And true, Porps to Fyfe is an upgrade

JamSainter · August 10, 2012, 05:50:58 PM

Quote from: Nieso FC on August 10, 2012, 04:27:29 PM
Porps was never intended to be a permanent fixture in your team was he?

Chappy always was so I would trade Porps at least that is an upgrade rather than a sideways trade.

Things change during a year. The run home during SC finals weeks, injury concerns and the like.
Since you CERTAINLY know the return date of Porps + his dream run home where he can basically feast on Melbourne and GCS I'd keep Porps and trade Chappy personally.

ubeaut · August 10, 2012, 06:35:32 PM

Quote from: JamSainter on August 10, 2012, 05:50:58 PM
Quote from: Nieso FC on August 10, 2012, 04:27:29 PM
Porps was never intended to be a permanent fixture in your team was he?

Chappy always was so I would trade Porps at least that is an upgrade rather than a sideways trade.
Things change during a year. The run home during SC finals weeks, injury concerns and the like.
Since you CERTAINLY know the return date of Porps + his dream run home where he can basically feast on Melbourne and GCS I'd keep Porps and trade Chappy personally.

What if Chappy plays next week? Have a look at the Cats website and tell me what u make of it.

Nieso FC · August 10, 2012, 07:34:43 PM

Chappy is only a slight calf strain isn't it