Trading Swan!!!!!!!! Please Help!

[maanco]

IF you help me i will do what i can to help you.  :D

Im in the schools  finals series and im in an elemination final this week, so i need to win. With Swan out i think i need to trade. This is my current team:

DEF: B. Deledio, M. Johnson, B. Goddard, B. Waters, G. Birchall, D. Heppell, A. Carrazzo (R. Conca, S. Shaw)
MID: D. Swan, M. Boyd, G. Ablett jnr, S. Thompson, S. Mitchell, J. Selwood (D. Smith, M. Baguley)
RUC: I. Maric, J. Giles (J. Redden, T. Campbell)
FWD: S. Sidebottom, B. Whitecross, R. O'Keefe, D. Martin, D. Zorko, A. Treloar, T. Adams (L. Franklin, T. Cloke)
Trades left: 3

Ive got a few options:
Option 1: Trade swan to Cotchin,
                .  This will leave me with $50,000 in the 
                 bank for my last trade. (probably Giles to
                 .Cox)
                  Cotchin has a predicted score in assissant coach of 124, but has only scored over 120 3 times this year.
Option 2: Trade Swan to Watson,
                This gives me $34,000, and i probably
                wont be able to trade giles to cox, so will
                 have to be a different ruck.
Option 3: Please comment on who i should trade him too if you think there is someone better!

I won't be trading Giles this week. The money would realy be for if someone hits a form slump or gets injured.

Thanks,
Maanco

[Madsnake]

I'd say Watson will be the higher scorer of the two, maybe just, and the way Giles has been scoring you may aswell save that trade for an injury later on.

[dejan]

leave giles mate hes ben good lately and hes got gold coast this week save ur trade and get rid of swan for watson only if u have to im keeping him

[maanco]

Thanks guys I won't be trading Giles this week but he won't keep these scores up for long  so I need the money for back up.

[stew42]

Giles also has a crazy low BE, don't drop him now.

[maanco]

im not dropping Giles now and hopefully not ever if he keeps this up. but if he starts scoring 60s he will have to go.

[LF]

Cotchin
this year
highest score 143 v Essendon at MCG
Lowest score 63 v Port
Lowest score at the MCG 88 highest 143
average for games at the MCG this year 110.3 played 10 games so far this year

Last games for Richmond this year
Bulldogs at MCG
Freo at Pattison
Bombers at MCG
Port at MCG

Previous scores v 4 final opponents
Bulldogs haven`t play them yet but score 79 against them last year in round 8
Freo 112
Bombers 143
Port 63

[LF]

Watson
this year
Highest score 139 v Port
Lowest score 82 v Saints
lowest score at the MCG 100 highest 128
average for games at the MCG this year 116.5 Bombers have only played 4 games there so far this year


Last games for Bombers this year
North at Etihad
Carlton at MCG
Richmond at MCG
Collingwood at MCG

previous scores against final 4 opponents this year
North 110
Carlton 100
Richmond 134
Collingwood 104

[maanco]

thanks luvfooty.
Who would you pick??

[LF]

thanks luvfooty.
Who would you pick??

Looking at the stats i`d probably lean towards Watson but then i`m a bit bias towards Cotchin because i actually have him in my team.

[JamSainter]

Since it is DT, Cotchin probably is your man, plus he has a slightly more favourable draw and has more midfield support unlike Watson.

[Spinking]

Of your choices mentioned I would go Watson, but consider Murphy and Pendles. Both reasonably cheap and proven guns.

[maanco]

Thanks guys looks like im going with Watson :)

[pcmaniman]

Not considering Beams?