Last downgrade option - Bell or Browne?

Started by Macca#23, August 10, 2012, 12:40:13 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Tom Bell or Andrew Browne?

Bell
0 (0%)
Browne
2 (100%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Macca#23

My last downgrade for the season is Lake down to either Tom Bell or Andrew Browne. Who has the better JS for the remainder of the season. I want to choose Browne for the extra 52k salary cap as I will be down to 1 trade after the trades, but his JS worries me.

Thoughts?

Jigsaw

I reckon Browne has higher JS, only marginally buy. The Bombers have a lot of injuries atm, so Browne should hang around for awhile longer.

Once Judd comes back into the side, I'm expecting Bell to make way. I'm a Carlton fan, so I know a thing or two about the ins and outs potential within the club.

Also, may as well in terms of having that extra 52k handy with your last trade.

Is this for D7,8 or 9 btw?

Macca#23

Well I either keep Lake who is struggling big time, or downgrade him to Browne/Bell, then play Shaw, Baguley, Browne/Bell for a week until I use my last trade next week to go Shaw > premium.

I just can't stand Lake being in my team any longer. He's been there all season, and I've been a part of his highs and his lows. He's been in horrible DT form and playing one of my 3 rookies wouldn't even hurt me that much.

Jigsaw

Ah right. Tough call for sure. Having some trades during the finals can be crucial.

If the rest of your team is set to go and you have the cover all around however, then using the last two trades on your defence might not be to bad an option. Are you in the top 4 but?

As annoying as Lake can be but, If you lack cover in other areas, then you may have to hold him and save the trades.

I can probably make out what your trying to do here but. Lake has a high B/E and you want to ditch him now before he leaks and make the final upgrade next week when Shaw rises slightly yeah? If so, understandable.

Macca#23

Quote from: Jigsaw on August 10, 2012, 01:03:43 AM
Ah right. Tough call for sure. Having some trades during the finals can be crucial.

If the rest of your team is set to go and you have the cover all around however, then using the last two trades on your defence might not be to bad an option. Are you in the top 4 but?

As annoying as Lake can be but, If you lack cover in other areas, then you may have to hold him and save the trades.

I can probably make out what your trying to do here but. Lake has a high B/E and you want to ditch him now before he leaks and make the final upgrade next week when Shaw rises slightly yeah? If so, understandable.

My forward line, midfield and rucks are finished, mydefence is the weak link.

I have Lids, MJ, BJ, Waters, Birchall, Lake, Carrazzo in my starting team. Really want to upgrade Lake before lockout tonight but still not sureon Browne/Bell.