What are you doing with Swan?

[its me lads]

In case you havent heard the news.........swan is out for 2 Decided tomake this poll for people who just want a quick answer.

i will probably hold him. main league i should win this week then week off and he will be back

have a read if you want

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/143883/default.aspx

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,66157.0.html

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,66153.0.html

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,66164.0.html

[Ricochet]

even with 4 trades left I'm holding. have a second chance in most my leagues so no point trading him unless i have to next week.

[Dave085]

Im debating with my self if i should do the following trades leaving me with only $3,700 and 1 trade...

Giles --> Cox and Gibson to S. Thompson...

Mids will be Boyd, Ablet, Thompson, Pendles, Watson, Selwood - Bench Swan, Miles.

I finished top 4 so im wondering if its worth it or not. Maybe ill just do it next week...

[T Dog]

even with 4 trades left I'm holding. have a second chance in most my leagues so no point trading him unless i have to next week.

Are you really relying on second chance ? I am going hard for the week off ..leaving any issues to sort put later..but buddy and swannie should be back by then..lol.. :o

[Ajax22]

Im debating with my self if i should do the following trades leaving me with only $3,700 and 1 trade...

Giles --> Cox and Gibson to S. Thompson...

Mids will be Boyd, Ablet, Thompson, Pendles, Watson, Selwood - Bench Swan, Miles.

I finished top 4 so im wondering if its worth it or not. Maybe ill just do it next week...

If you were gonna do something along those lines I would be bringing in a DPP player (or pure forward) that might be able to score similarly to Thompson. You should be able to find one that can perform well over 4 rounds. This means that when Swan returns you can just move this player into the forward line to play instead of someone like Martin rather than leaving say a Selwood on the bench. This week especially Thompsons a fairly good chance to cop a hard tag

[Dave085]

Im debating with my self if i should do the following trades leaving me with only $3,700 and 1 trade...

Giles --> Cox and Gibson to S. Thompson...

Mids will be Boyd, Ablet, Thompson, Pendles, Watson, Selwood - Bench Swan, Miles.

I finished top 4 so im wondering if its worth it or not. Maybe ill just do it next week...

If you were gonna do something along those lines I would be bringing in a DPP player (or pure forward) that might be able to score similarly to Thompson. You should be able to find one that can perform well over 4 rounds. This means that when Swan returns you can just move this player into the forward line to play instead of someone like Martin rather than leaving say a Selwood on the bench. This week especially Thompsons a fairly good chance to cop a hard tag

Thanks mate, just thought of a few solutions... heres my poll if you have some spare time. Would appreciate it... http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,66167.0.html

[Holz]

pretty simple in my eyes, top 4 hold, bottom 4 and have a few trades up your sleave than trade.

[Ricochet]

even with 4 trades left I'm holding. have a second chance in most my leagues so no point trading him unless i have to next week.

Are you really relying on second chance ? I am going hard for the week off ..leaving any issues to sort put later..but buddy and swannie should be back by then..lol.. :o

if i win i don't need to use the trade, and if i lose then i use the trade next week

[TheBeatles]

even with 4 trades left I'm holding. have a second chance in most my leagues so no point trading him unless i have to next week.

Are you really relying on second chance ? I am going hard for the week off ..leaving any issues to sort put later..but buddy and swannie should be back by then..lol.. :o

if i win i don't need to use the trade, and if i lose then i use the trade next week

+1

[Torpedo10]

If you have Gibson on the bench atm don't bother trading. It will barely lose you any points if any as Gibson is pumping 110s each week.

[Master Q]

Think I'm going to trade him. That'll leave me with -1  :P

0 trades  :(

[Zombie2.5]

If you have Gibson on the bench atm don't bother trading. It will barely lose you any points if any as Gibson is pumping 110s each week.

Gibson is great cover... He's been scoring 100's like Swanny anyways... If your opponent has Swan & Gibson too, then you wouldn't gain much points with say Thommo over Gibson... And Gibson scored more than Thommo last week anyways...

[Adamant]

Holding...I think  :P

[chaosAD]

i finished top 4 and im trading, getting rid of Broughton and Swan for Scotland and J Watson,

[KoopKicka]

If youre contemplating trading him out I suppose the question you need to ask yourself are you going to cope with Swan possibly being in your opponents column in the PF/GF?