Rockliff to Thompson

[penskifile]

What are peoples thoughts on this trade? I am happy with the rest of my team and have good cover in all positions. Both these players have relatively easy runs home, but i think Thompson is a slightly safer bet. Doing this trade will leave me with 1 trade.

[makita]

i have rockliff also, I'm going to stick it out with him. he has a reasonable draw to finish and can put out big numbers. waste of a trade if u ask me. over the 4 weeks i don't see thompson scoring to much more, especially if rocky throws out a big score one week.

save the trade incase one of ur guns goes down so u can still sideways him for another premo.

[avitt]

I have Thompson and am still very wary of what Sanderson said midseason, about resting his players in the leadup to finals..
If you want to do that trade, I'd be making sure that your final trade is still with you for the GF in case he gets a rest against the Gold Coast!

[korza]

In my opinion, it's a coinflip, as the old saying goes horses for courses.

[ubeaut]

i have rockliff also, I'm going to stick it out with him. he has a reasonable draw to finish and can put out big numbers. waste of a trade if u ask me. over the 4 weeks i don't see thompson scoring to much more, especially if rocky throws out a big score one week.

save the trade incase one of ur guns goes down so u can still sideways him for another premo.

I think u should get GAJ but it's up to u.

However I wouldn't trade Rocky for Thompson. Crows should sow up top 4 or even 2 in the next 2 rounds. Then they have Dees and GC. Thompson is a prime candidate for a rest.

[juzztheball]

Thompson scored a whopping 78 this week and is due for a rest.

[strikes91]

no point, like others have said, save it

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :o
I've got both of them, and will keep them pending selections for round 23. With 2 trades left ( same as me ) I would definitely hold off trading.