Where will more points be gained?

[camo15]

Quite straightforward, I'm looking to burn two trades for finals.

These options are assuming that Tippet/Broughton are both back this week (which seems likely).

If anyone wants some extra information regarding my team, I'll post it

[bensl]

well if broughton is out for the season then surely trading him will gain the most points?

hard to know without seeing your team.

[camo15]

I'll bold the current issues I have with my team.

Backline: H Shaw, Scotland, Goddard, Deledio, M Johnson, Broughton, Lake, Bench: Smedts (Covering Broughton), Boumann

Midfield: Swan, Abblett, Dal Santo, Selwood, Boyd, Watson, Bench: Kerridge, Stevens

Rucks: McEvoy, Stepheson, Bench: Campbell, J Hall,

Forward: Franklin, Tippet, Sidebottom, N Riedwolt, Zorko, Chapman, Harvey, Bench: Dell Olio, Murdoch

I think Broughton is facing a test this week to see if he's ready.

I have 4 trades left and 61k in the bank, so providing Tippet, Broughton, Franklin are all back I can downgrade smedts to Wrightley/Browne and Upgrade any of the options in the poll to the player listed. What I'm asking is where will I gain more points.

[spenc13]

broughts gone for the season... read a paper

[camo15]

I have no idea how I missed out on that info,

So it looks like its between Carazzo and Waters, I'm leading towards Carazzo due to proven consistency.

[Spinking]

Get Waters in my opinion. Carazzo has been great this season, but as we saw last weekend he can go missing occasionally when doing a job on someone.

[Braddles10]

Get Waters for Broughton. Been beasting it lately, and is vital to West Coasts team. Prepare yourself for the tidal wave of incoming points!

[blue]

 Broughton has to go, but upgrading the big O should be on the cards as well

[Wacky Tiger]

FWIW With West out for 3-4 weeks Big O would be handy bench cover. I'd keep him

[dmac07]

Broughton to waters, then in a week or two if you still have to other two trades, big o to hudson/mummy

[HappyDEZ]

I agree with most of the above, Broughts to Waters & upgrade the Big O.

[HappyDEZ]

FWIW With West out for 3-4 weeks Big O would be handy bench cover. I'd keep him

I do agree that he could be handy bench cover, but when you have him as a starting ruck with finals starting this week I reckon ya gotta pull the trigger on an upgrade. More importantly, what does FWIW mean?

[camo15]

Well, swans suspension has really messed that up.

Here's what Im now thinking of doing:

Swan > Pendlebury
Broughton > Dempsey/Burgoyne/Suckling

Then next week

Smedts > Rookie
Big O > Any Ruckmen below 500k

Or,

Swan > Kennedy/Thompson/ A cheaper premium mid.
Broughton > Birchall/Hurn/Maybe Waters or Carazzo if I grab a cheap Mid for Swan

Then a similar Smedts/Big O ruck upgrade as above.