Baguley a good D8/M7?

[PowerBug]

I currently have S.Shaw, Tomlinson and Baguley in the mids. Was looking at downgrading S.Shaw to McIntyre (Using DPP) but am concerned over whether Baguley is good enough cover as a D8.

It's not just a personal question though, others may find it handy too, so i decided to chuck this poll up.

All thoughts appreciated. :)

[POK252]

Bit unsure on what you mean  ??? You say you have Tomlinson, Bags and Shaw in MIDS, i guess you mean DEF.
If you trade Shaw what will your final benches be??

[tbagrocks]

 mids eh: haha PB has other things on his mind :P

[tbagrocks]

you could do worse than Sammy as your D7

[Adamant]

Yes

[PowerBug]

Bit unsure on what you mean  ??? You say you have Tomlinson, Bags and Shaw in MIDS, i guess you mean DEF.
If you trade Shaw what will your final benches be??

i have Shaw and Tomlinson *comma* and baguley in the mids. :) Bad grammar got the better of me there. So that's why i said about the DPP trade. :)

Hope that clears it up. :D Back to the voting, would like an essendon supporters' view (We have plenty on here) as to whether they think he has good JS and what his role is like. :)

[PowerBug]

looking like a pretty solid yes to me! :D Will have my proposed trades up later in the week. :)

[Scrads]

bags is good cover, do you have a MF link though ? players like Zorko, Treloar, Smith are probs better for M7 though...

[PowerBug]

bags is good cover, do you have a MF link though ? players like Zorko, Treloar, Smith are probs better for M7 though...

I don't need him for M7, i have Gibson. I just posed the question coz it can help everyone, not just myself. :)