My 2 worst pick ups of the year, 1 has to go

[The Supercoach]

My line up

back: carrazzo, birchall, lids, scott d thom, yarran, goddard, fisher (s shaw and spurr)

fwd: Harvey, Cloke, SIDebottom, Franklin, Chapman, Zorko, Martin (couch and hall)

[ubeaut]

How many trades u got ? Any Cash?

First I would rather Pav or Beams or O'Keefe. But it's up to u.

Your forward line is more of a concern than ur backs. U can play Thompson/Shaw (I reckon Shaw is a better option) as D7/D8
But u have shaky cover (Hall/Couch) and Travis Joke in the fwds.

Have u got a mid DPP cover(on ur mid bench like Treloar)to use instead of Hall/Couch? If so maybe get rid of Cloke. If not can u make cash elsewhere (downgrade Spurr?) and keep Cloke as backup? It all depends on trades and cash left and league vs overall etc..

Keep in mind that Cloke is the sort of annoying player that could play crap 4 weeks on end and then pump out a 120 vs Bombers in round 23.

[tbagrocks]

two words, Taylor Walker

[Adamant]

Cloke to Roughy.

[The Supercoach]

i have 3 trades left with 223,300 in the bank, i cant afford okeefe pav or beaams, the player i put in the poll were the best i could afford, no dpp cover so im struggling bad. I finished 5th and flowering 1 game off 2nd as i have the highest %! >:(! Tex Walker gets suspended to much for my liking, and with my terrible bench cover i thinks its tooo risky

[ubeaut]

What about Hall > Fyfe/Goodes. Risky but could pay off. Then u keep Cloke as back up. 2 trades left.
Could also do Thompson/Spurr > Browne/other rookie keep 220 K and 1 trade left.?

Or just do that downgrade and get Beams/Pav/O'keefe for Hall. And 1 trade left.