Is his new BE relevant?

[jamesalex]

What to do?

1. S.Shaw (BE-4) to A.Browne, Horsely to Pendles.- This option allows me to get a decent downgrade option in Browne, however Shaw is great bench cover, will make more cash with a BE of 4, and my other defender on the bench is Darley, who isn't playing, so Browne and Darley as bench cover isn't ideal (especially since Malceski's JS still isn't certain.)

2. T.Adams (BE-71) to Couch/any forward rookie, Jmac/Horsely to Pendles.- Allows me to get Adams out at a good time, however there are no decent downgrade options, so will most likely have to get Couch or a debutant (if any.). This shouldn't matter too much, since Treloar is my other forward bench? Allows me to trade Jmac as well who may be less likely to play than Horsely.

Which option?
Thanks a lot.

[slipknot_4]

do the adams 1 at least need 1 emergency in each line just in case

[Footyrulz]

I would trade adams, i think its more important to have 1 good emergency on each line than having 1 more decent forward.

[jamesalex]

Thanks, realized there's another option...

Gibson to Couch/forward rookie (gives me valuable DPP, however my midfield bench will be McDonald and Couch/Treloar/Adams)
Horsely to Pendles.

Viable option, or is Gibson too good cover to trade? Just need a few opinions before i add it to the poll.

[LF]

Gibson is far better cover than Old Mac and Couch.Even Adams and Treloar aren't garaunteed games with GWS resting policy(I have Treloar and dread the team announcements)
Old Mac is not really getting games and Couch has had 1 game Gibson looks set in the Roos team and doesn't look like getting dropped.

[jamesalex]

Gibson is far better cover than Old Mac and Couch.Even Adams and Treloar aren't garaunteed games with GWS resting policy(I have Treloar and dread the team announcements)
Old Mac is not really getting games and Couch has had 1 game Gibson looks set in the Roos team and doesn't look like getting dropped.

Yeah I think GIbson is just scoring too well to trade.

[jamesalex]

bump