Harley Bennell - 2013 DT Smokey

Started by Tominator, August 05, 2012, 05:33:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Scrads

Depends what your definition of a 'Smokie' is but I wouldn't call him one. Will end up being popular if he retains Forward status.

Kellogscrunchynut

4 goals today should help his case for MPP selection next year.

Justin Bieber

You just posted this thread, so not a Smokie anymore.

Windigo

Isn't a really smokey. Was always gunna be in my side, and probably a lot of others next year with DPP.

Especially with Beams & Sidey losing their DPP, IMO.  :P

KoopKicka

Quote from: Adamant on August 05, 2012, 07:00:36 PM
Quote from: KoopKicka on August 05, 2012, 06:15:33 PM
Actually, if Boak goes Im locking in Matty Broadbent as my 2013 smokey. Should be around 350k
I like the look of Broadbent but he will be closer to 420k with his 80 odd avg  :-\

Hes 370 at the moment I believe, I think he might rise to 400k, maybe even 420k actually youre right :/ but if hes uunder 400k and if Boaks gone Im jumping on him.

pommyadam

as a mid, not for me
as a dpp, then maybe

but far too inconsistent for my liking, which rules him out a bit
i may jump on next season (if GC improve), but he only scores well when GC do

Zombie2.5

Will be pretty pricey.

If he has a M/F status still, under $350k is a bargain if he breakouts for real next year.
Mid only, not really a lock, but will become a smoky.


Anyone looking at David Swallow for 3rd year??

Tominator

Quote from: KoopKicka on August 05, 2012, 06:15:33 PM
Actually, if Boak goes Im locking in Matty Broadbent as my 2013 smokey. Should be around 350k
you mean when Boak goes

Hard to see him staying with the current situation down there

Holz

Quote from: Zombie2.5 on August 06, 2012, 01:42:40 AM
Will be pretty pricey.

If he has a M/F status still, under $350k is a bargain if he breakouts for real next year.
Mid only, not really a lock, but will become a smoky.


Anyone looking at David Swallow for 3rd year??

Swallow as a mid over dpp bennell any day. Injury has held swallow back this year and will lift his average 20 points. I have never picked a mid price mid before but I'm about a 80% chance to next year

Ziplock

swallow> bennell.

I'll probs take bennell in the fwd line- worst case scenario, he ends up like martin this year.

HBTD22

Bennell an absolute lock if he's a DPP... also going to seriously look at Danny Stanley.

me

yeah wouldn't call him a smoky anymore, but a couple more big scores could make his price too high for me... he will be tagged a lot in his career

Windigo

Quote from: me on August 06, 2012, 01:26:48 PM
yeah wouldn't call him a smoky anymore, but a couple more big scores could make his price too high for me... he will be tagged a lot in his career

Getting tagged now & is handling fairly well..

Toga

yep i'll have a look at him if he keeps his MPP. but will also look at david swallow in the midfield for sure! i have a feeling GCS will recover from their second year blues and come out strong next year, so i'll be jumping on a few of them!!

The F.A.R.K.