Ask Q (3/8/12)

[Master Q]

Ask me your questions and I'll give you my honest opinion!

Deadline: 6:20 EST

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

[waalitj]

who to play in defence - baguley or sam shaw

thanks

appreciated

[Master Q]

who to play in defence - baguley or sam shaw

thanks

appreciated

Baguley is in some good form.

[kiss01]

Will Steve Johnson play tonight?

[LaHug]

I have done maths, fears of injury, prices, personal opinions, etc. etc. and can't split these 3 trade options...

$45,400 in the bank, 4 trades remaining

1) This week: Broughton to Bell, Stanton to Boyd. Then: Ellis to Scotland/Waters. Leaves me with approx. $1500.
Pros: Gets Boyd now and leaves another week to choose between Scotland and Waters, don't have to field Gibson this week. Cons: Boyd's BE is 169, leaves me with less cash, have to field Ellis or Spurr this week.

2) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Scotland. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $26.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, nets the most cash. Cons: Scotland plays Sydney this week, have to field Gibson.

3) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Waters. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $20.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, Waters likely to ton up in Derby. Cons: Waters is injury/suspension prone, have to field Gibson.

Can't split them. Help?

[Master Q]

Will Steve Johnson play tonight?

I have a funny feeling he won't. Wait till final teams though.

[tbagrocks]

Q great stuff, thanks for your time again mate, Big Steph is he likely to do better or stick with Giles?

[Master Q]

Q great stuff, thanks for your time again mate, Big Steph is he likely to do better or stick with Giles?

Gotta stick with Giles.

[LaHug]

You skipped my question... :'(

[miegs3]

Last two trades and $71,000 in the bank.
A loss this week could have me out of the 8 (shocking luck), anyway should I make moves to clear the money that is sitting on my bench and who should I get that will smash it this week and remain hot for finals?

Team: (trade thoughts in bold)
Backs: Deledio, Scotland, Suckling, Goddard, Adcock, Carrazzo, Smedts (Broughton, Shaw)
Mids: Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Mitchell, Selwood, Pendlebury (Gibson, Miles)
Rucks: Cox, Maric (Redden, Campbell)
Forwards: Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Chapman, Porplyzia, Zorko, Goodes, Murdoch (Franklin, Tomlinson)

My Opponent: (uniques in bold)
Backs: Deledio, Goddard, Waters, Adcock, Carrazzo, Morris, Yarran (Shaw, Baguley)
Mids: Swan, Boyd, Watson, Ablett, Mitchell, Pendlebury (Gibson, Robinson)
Rucks: Jacobs, Griffin (Redden, Campbell)
Forwards: Beams, Sidebottom, Martin, Cloke, Porplyzia, Zorko, Goodes (Franklin, Treloar)

[georgekera11]

Basic simple question who to start?

Jenkins or Campbell ?

[TryAnHit]

Option A: Milera to Goodes / Robbo to Dangerfield / Keep Franklin

Option B: Milera to fyfe / Franklin to Pavlich / Keep Robbo

Current forward

Beams / Sidey / Johnson / Whitecross / Zorko / Franklin / Robbo / [milera] / [crozier]

So goodes / fyfe will be cover as both my cover got dropped / injured

Or any other forwards. Can no afford ROK. But how about chapman? figured Pav / Danger since they have easy run home

[Capper]

will you accept my challenge???

[EZA100]

Which trade should i do ellis - suckling or ward/barlow/kennedy (which one) - murphy

[Master Q]

I have done maths, fears of injury, prices, personal opinions, etc. etc. and can't split these 3 trade options...

$45,400 in the bank, 4 trades remaining

1) This week: Broughton to Bell, Stanton to Boyd. Then: Ellis to Scotland/Waters. Leaves me with approx. $1500.
Pros: Gets Boyd now and leaves another week to choose between Scotland and Waters, don't have to field Gibson this week. Cons: Boyd's BE is 169, leaves me with less cash, have to field Ellis or Spurr this week.

2) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Scotland. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $26.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, nets the most cash. Cons: Scotland plays Sydney this week, have to field Gibson.

3) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Waters. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $20.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, Waters likely to ton up in Derby. Cons: Waters is injury/suspension prone, have to field Gibson.

Can't split them. Help?

Yep! Is hard to split them! I'd be looking at 2 or 3 as Stanton is still a chance to score...