who to keep ?????

[buzza]

upgrading a backman, who to keep out of ellis or shaw ?
and who to ungrade to, waters or suckling ?

[fertalong]

I'd keep shaw just because he has more money to make. They should score about the same anyway.
Also, waters over suckling.

[rider]

shaw - good draw, and he has proved can hit the high notes against poor opposition

[tbagrocks]

Ellis to Waters looks the best bet

[bomdiggity]

Ellis to Waters looks the best bet

+1 both good but i'd keep shaw