Scotland or Waters? (Last Defence Upgrade)

[Jigsaw]

Upgrading Hargrave either this week or next. Just wondering what everyone's opinion is on this one. Pros and cons for both make it tough to split them.

[tbagrocks]

pro being Scotland is the second best defencive Dter around

[Jigsaw]

pro being Scotland is the second best defencive Dter around

Agreed there. Though, when Waters gets going he can dish out the big numbers.

I must admit though, I am leaning towards bringing in Scotland more so.

[Ajax22]

Scotland. Consistently good every week and doesn't have those minor injury/resting concerns that Waters has

[Jigsaw]

Have gone with Scotland so far, although my poll is saying otherwise.

Thinking Scotland has the easier run ahead and is less likely to randomly be a late withdrawal.

[Spinking]

Go Scotland. Probably about par on scoring potential. Scotland just a bit more durable...

[HappyDEZ]

It would be nice to have 'em both, but if you can only have one, Scotland for mine.

[nostradamus]

Scotland is more consistent and durable, but Waters is a competitive beast and can pump out higher scores

.....tough choice, if l were going for consistency l'd take Scotland, but if it was a higher ceiling l wanted Waters would be my man. So really it depends what you're after l suppose.

l have both  :)  my backline is......... Delideo, Waters, Scotland, Carrazzo, Shaw, Goddard, Suckling (S.Shaw, Darley)

[Chelskiman]

Scotland.  Just.  Waters has a higher ceiling though.  I've been lucky with these two as I held them both when a lot of people got trigger happy.  8)